Nipples too sore, can't bf, getting depressed

Just felt I needed to post this.

Bub was born 2 weeks early on the 14th of Feb, and it's been really tough. He had problems attaching and in the process, my nipples got really sore to the point that each time bub latched on, it was so painful that it made my cry.
At the end of the hospital stay, I was expressing to get milk, still very little at 20ml, and then topping up with formula. I could no longer have bub at my breast. When we left the hospital, the lactation consultant suggested trying a nipple shield.

The whole process at home was expressing every 3 hrs, taking 40mins, then feeding with breastmilk and then topping up with formula, then sterilising everything. Everything was so focused on feeding bub and I hardly had any sleep, most 1 hr, 1.5 hrs. DH was helping with the feeding but he was getting tired too. And my depression was getting to him. The whole problem is that my nipples are really sore and painful. Bub wasnt attaching properly and chomping on them. I thought it would be better and tried on Thursday with a nipple shield. At first it was good, bub was better at attaching so I was really happy. I tried again later in the day and it just got so painful that when bub latched on, it made me cry.
Anyway, constant expressing didnt increase my milk flow and having bub on was so painful. The whole process was really making me depressed. I was sinking into depression and resentment that he had come early. Seeing all the posts in my belly buddies about getting ready for bub, and the excitement and still having time to do stuff made me feel worse. I wasnt ready for bub, and I want/wanted time to myself. I feel cheated.
I went to the hospital for bub's follow up visit today and the lactation consultant was very worried that I was getting depressed. She said there's nothing wrong with switching to formula. She said that it's better for the baby to have formula than a mother who's depressed and that it's going to affect him.
She said we could try molitium (i think) to try to increase the prolactin levels to increase the milk. It's been reducing the last couple of days, probably because I've been dreading the pump more and more and the whole process was making me really tired and upset. I've been crying and crying so, my milk has been reducing too.
So anyway, we decided that I'll stop expressing for the next few days and put bub on formula. Early next week, we'll go see my GP and discuss getting molitium, the side-effects.
I just still feel guilty about not being able to bf and giving bub the best. But it's become so painful.. I still feel it's my fault. I feel upset and angry and resentful that I lost time to myself. I had plans and now everything's changed forever. I keep crying and telling DH it's not fair and that I cant do this feeding thing. Even when I went to hossy, and the midwife said I was 1cm dilated, I was like it can't be, I don't want to have bub yet, I'm not ready.
But as the lactation consultant said it's better to have formula than a depressed mother. I still havent developed a maternal feeling towards bub, I know this is a child that I have to look after, but I dont have that bond or attachment yet.

I hope someone can share their experience with me, I feel guilty for not being able to bf, and I feel guilty for not having a bond with my baby, I feel guilty for resenting the fact that he came early (not him tho) and I feel guilty for feeling guilty. I feel it's all my fault.
I feel horrid for feeling this way.

Deleted

Thanks so much Bindy. You made me feel better.
I guess I had really wonderful pregnancy, I really enjoyed it and didnt quite want it to end just yet. And I guess in a way it's all come crashing down, it's the hormones too...

I will try to get a good night's sleep. At least with formula you can sleep and someone else can do the feeding.

Thanks again, it means a lot to me. And I'm really glad everything worked out for you and Madeline. I know, formula isnt the end of the world, I was fed on formula too, and I turned out ok.
xoxoxoxxo

Deleted

Thanks again.
A quick question. I'm not expressing today, should I do anything or just let the milk supply die down. I dont want to get mastitis....

I'm not going to repeat what Bindy has said, as her words are very wise indeed. But, I just wanted to say, it doesn't matter if you formula feed or breast feed, you're still going to raise, a happy, healthy baby who will thrive on your love!

Huge hugs!!! :hug:

Celsie. xoxox

Deleted

OMG hun congrats on the birth of bubs!!! :dance:

Im not going to tell you not to breastfeed and formula feed vice versa but I just wanted to say I had the same problem as you and DD ended up being formula feed. She is a healthy 14 month old & while I would have liked to BF her I know the best decision I could at the time.

I hope BF does work out for you but if not dont feel guilty hun XX

Prama, I know how you feel, so hugs to you:hug: I also had a wonderful pregnancy and even though I knew life would be changed forever, the reality of it all hit me hard in hospital. The pressure from midwives, family and the wider community to breastfeed made me feel like a failure when I couldn't get it to work right away. Cracked, bleeding nipples and feeding all the time didn't feel good and when DS did go to sleep I freaked out everytime he stirred and wished like crazy that he wouldn't wake up because I dreaded feeding... that led to the guilt you know about. 10 weeks later things are getting better and I have a formula contingency plan for if I get a third bout of mastitis - because personal sanity and being happy and healthy mean I can look after my boy and that's so much more important than meeting anyone else's expectations and standards. My mum also reminded me that noone can make me feel guilty without my permission. Find what works for you - If breastfeeding is something really important to you, then do what you can to try and make it work, but remember that you are NOT a failure if you decide it's not for you. You carried this baby and brought him into the world - that's the start of a success story!

Prama...you ARE giving your baby the best!

You are way more than milk to your little one...you are love, comfort, cuddles, security, nurturing...and most importantly...you are mummy!

Hang in there...it will get sorted out, whether it's BF-ing or formula...

Just give yourself the break you need and know that it WILL BE OKAY!

Prama, the other ladies have written some wonderful posts, so I don't feel there is much to add. I personally hate all the bullsh$t pressure that is put upon us women to "give our children the best" meaning to breastfeed. Surely if we have a roof over our children's heads, blankets to keep them warm at night, a loving and affectionate home, and a full belly - then it shouldn't matter where the food comes from. Honey, I only fed DS for 2.5 days, and then switched to formula because I started HATING him for causing me such pain - pain that nobody ever told me about. Sure some people said, oh its not easy, but not one person ever told me it was PAINFUL. My son is thriving and I don't regret - not even for one damn second - the fact that I switched to formula. I fully believe that women should do what is best for themselves AND their baby - not what society "thinks" they should be doing.
Don't be so hard on yourself, you are doing a GREAT job. Give yourself a lot of pats on the back for surviving the most difficult week (and a bit!) of your life!!! Take care

thanks so much girls.... it does make a difference knowing someone else has gone thru the same.
lewis's mummy - how did you get back into bf?
linz - thanks! great belly shot.
celsie, monnie - thank you
Aricyn's mum - thats exactly what i thought, everyone talks abt how wonderful it is. no one told me the pain, sore and cracked nipples


my breasts are getting really painful fr not expressing, should I express a little to ease the pain?

Hi,

It sounds like the last week or so have been very overwhelming for you. It's a tough time having a new baby, and especially when things have been going so well during the pregnancy, and then the feeding is not going so well.
the first rule is "feed the baby" Your little one needs to be fed, and it sounds as if breastfeeding was just so, so difficult for you. Would you want to share a bit about the birth with us? Coming 2 weeks ealy had thrown up a whole new set of challeges for you - it wouldn't have been the case (prob) if he was full term. But, you had no control over that. It is plain from your e-mail that you have done everything you can for your little one, including the decision to put him on formula. Guilt is such a wasted emotion. You have to know you are a great mum.
Breastfeeding often affords a little flexibility - if you want to give it another go, you could consider getting a thorough assessment from an independant LC. But, if in the morning, your heart tells you you have made the right decision, go with that. Time will reveal a lot about what happened with your little one. No-one can help the circumstances that surrounded his arrival
Look after yourself
Barb

Deleted

prama,

I just wanted to share with you my experience, and it's not pro-BFing but very much pro-mum, okay?

When I had Charlie I honestly believe BFing would be a breeze for me because I'd BFed all my older (now teenaged) kids successfully. But the reality was quite different. His mouth was small and my nipples too big and my experience at the hospital saw the midwives telling me to squeeze more of my nipple into his mouth, which made him gag or detach and made me miserable. In the end, whenever no one was looking, I let him suck as he felt like, and as a result, he fed well and gained weight, but by the 3rd day my nipples were cracked and bleeding and I was in the most excruciating pain. Everytime Charlie latched on, I cried and cried in agony.

My DH asked me to stop, to move him on to formula, he couldn't bear to see me in so much pain. But what made me persist was that I remembered and have experienced what it's like to BF into my baby's toddlerhood. It was different for me because I knew if I stood the pain, if I persisted, if I just get past the initial problems, there was going to be this incredible payoff - an amazing, fulfilling BFing relationship. I can't imagine if I was a new mum, and if I had faced that first time. I'm pretty sure I would have given up, because I wouldn't have known that if I got past it, it would be wonderful.

I'm not going to blather on about Breast is Best because we all know all that. But what I will say is that the pain did subside a little after 3 or 4 days, and to a bearable level in a few weeks, and while there was still discomfort, we both got better at it. In fact I continued to have problems on and off (and I'm sure there are threads I've posted about in somewhere on BB) eg Mastitis, cracked nipples (again) and a blister, but in the end, it was the amazing experience I knew it would eventually be. When I did wean, I mourned for a very long time because the good memories of BFing so far outweighed the bad it wasn't funny.

You will find women on BB who are passionate about BFing. And that's because BFing is not easy, it hurts and it's tiring and you never get enough support. And no one tells you that before baby comes. But for those who do end up sticking it out, it feels like an achievement, and they want to let other women know that they aren't alone in their pain and their sleep deprivation and their helplessness. You aren't alone.

And if in the end, the only thing that will save your sanity is FFing, then do it and don't feel guilty for making the best, most informed decision for you and your baby. But whatever your decision, know you'll have people there who have been through it and know how hard it is, and how hard you're trying, and who know you're a good mother no matter what.

Owwweee Prama, I remember, putting off feeds because I knew the feed would hurt, oh the soreness! I remember dreading each feed for awhile there. And we didn't even have the issues of bub coming early, bet that knocked you for six! :hug:

Can't really add to what the others have said. I know my mum loves me, and that's because of a whole lifetime of her actions, I can't even remember being breastfed.

I just wondered, if you express, as is comfortable, to keep a bit of supply, then that could give you a bit of time to give it another shot once you're in the right headspace? No pressure, it's just a thought.

Prama - I really feel for you, I went through the exact same thing. It was awful but I managed to get through it.

DS was born on his due date but his mouth was small and my nipples are large and we just couldn't seem to get enough in his mouth. I was in agony and dreaded every feed. I saw so many differnt LC and nurses and while BF seemed to go ok while they were there to help, as soon as they were gone it was excruciating again.

My Dr gave me tyleonl 3 which helped a lot and my husband gave me tons of encouragement, which also helped a lot. I didn't want to FF as I felt I was letting him down but the pain of BF was driving me insane and I was crying all the time too.

My first experience with pumping was with a crummy electric pump and it just didn't work. I started supplementing with formula to give my poor nipples a break, but I kept at the BF as much as I could stand and then topped up with formula.

Then someone lent me an Advent manual pump. It was so easy and pain free that I pumped (with a bit of FF) for 4 days to allow my nipples to heal, then I gradually started adding back in BF. Slowly I cut back on FF and then dropped the FF altogether and alternated bewteen BF and pumping. Eventually I was able to stop pumping as well.

It took 3 months but we are finally at the point where DS is 100% BF and I only pump if I go out and leave DH to babysit. My nipples are no longer read and sore and I am so glad I perservered. If it wasn't for a supportive husband, support from people here, ( ha ha and looking at the price of formula) I would never have made it.

If you can hang in there I promise it will get easier. If you really can't though it's not the end of the world. FF is definately better than being depressed and it's really not that big of a deal. You need to do what's best for you and baby and not worry about pressure from anyone. I was a FF baby and I think I turned out just fine. I hope it gets easier for you really soon!!

Prama, I can totally relate to your feelings about bub coming early. My second DS arrived 3 1/2 weeks early, totally unexpectedly and with just a 3 hour labour. His early arrival threw everything into chaos - DH's leave plans had to change, our plans for DS1 while I was in hossy couldn't happen, nothing was ready etc. I felt totally out of control and TBH with such a quick labour I hadn't had time to get my head around the fact that he was coming early. But what I can tell you is that over time, you will get over it, and you will feel less resentment. But it will take time.

WRT the feeding, I haven't been in your situation, but I agree that whatever you do is the right thing. You need to do what you need to do, and as hard as it is, try not to feel guilt over it. Feeding definitely does get easier, so if you get past this you will likely enjoy bfing, but if the formula is working better for you, then so be it. Please look after yourself. Mother guilt is a horrible thing and it doesn't matter what you do, you will feel it from time to time. It is important that you are doing well, so do take care of you. Best of luck to you, I think things will seem a lot better soon.

Deleted

prama,

it seems there are a few members who are here promoting FF (in a BFing support forum, where they wouldn't allow it if a BFer were saying the same in the FF forum) and I won't argue that sometimes it's an option. Esp if you're in pain, it's the easier option at that time, no doubt about it. But I hope in all the FF advocating in here, you don't miss the message that as hard as BFing is, a BFing relationship can be an incredible, wonderful thing. And while it's not about how much you love or don't love your baby, it's about an aspect of parenting that cannot be replicated by FFing. But everything has an opportunity cost, and you must weigh these out:

FF means no pain now
BFing means bearing the pain for a kind of relationship you don't get FFing.

I can't explain how wonderful that relationship is to someone who hasn't been there, but note the women who have BFed before who cannot now, they mourn so much. Or the ladies who BFed for a long time, they absolutely believe the pain is worth it.

So FFers, while we welcome your contributions, please don't discount what the encouragement and support the BFers have given in the BFing support thread.

Sushee, I'm sorry if I came across that way.. I really do apologise. I was just being supportive and putting across my story, so Prama wouldn't feel alone. I think the worst thing about being in pain with a new baby is that you do feel alone and that nobody can possibly understand what you are going through. I'm not against BF, I'm actually in awe of anyone who can do it, because it didn't work for me. I haven't made the decision whether or not to try to BF with this one, and I hope that if I do and I have struggles, then I can turn to BB and have some support (something I never had with the first struggle). I'm truly sorry if my post came across as anything against BF, I blame pregnancy brain for any wrong words, cos sometimes its hard to find the right words to express what I want to say. ;)
Prama - good luck in whatever you decide to do.

Deleted

it's taken me all day to write this. It's very long!!


Thank you so much, reading everyone's experiences makes me feel I'm not alone... When we went to the bf classes, they made it seem like everyone can, and the women who cant are the ones who have medical conditions. I did ask the lady, can everyone really bf and she said yes. They never said anything abt sore, cracked nipples and its effect on you. Nothing about the psychological effects.

thanks barb, here's my experience.
I enjoyed my pregnancy, I was very active, swimming twice a week plus yoga, putting on 12kgs. I felt wonderful, except the last few weeks I was feeling heavier. People fussed over me. The only down side was I couldnt sleep anymore. I finished work on the 1st and was looking forward to having the month off. Bub came almost 2 week after I finished work. The day I started contractions, I was going to wash all his clothes, sort out the nursery, there was still much to do with the nursery. He was born just past midnight on Thursday, the 14th and I had a pedicure appt, just one last chance to spoil myself.

I had irregular contractions early Wednesday morning, I thought they were just BH as the timing was all over the place. I rang the hospital at 4am and they told me sounds like false labour and told me to take some Panadeine. Plus I could walk and talk during the contractions so I still thought they were BH. They still continued, so about almost noon or so I rang the hospital again, and they said wait and see unless I really want to come in. The contractions were still very irregular, 5 mins apart, then 12, then 5 again, 20mins etc.
By 3pm I had enough and if this is false labour I wanted it to stop. So went to the hospital, at 4pm the midwife said I was 1 cm dilated and I was having the baby.
I was like, no, I dont want to have this baby today, I'm not ready. Ive got 2 weeks to go. This cant be happening.
(All the girls in my Belly Buddies group were so wanting their bubs to come out but I still wanted to have my time and wait till the due date)

Anyway, they sent us home and told us to come back when I had 3 contractions in 10 mins. Finally abt 9pm they got regular so we went back. At 10pm, I was already 8-9cm dilated. No time for anything anymore. I had gas as it got too much. I remember saying at the end 'I cant do this anymore, I want to go home'
I wasnt excited abt bub coming. I feel terrible saying this.

When I first looked at him, I didnt bond with him. I knew he was my child but nothing maternal kicked in.

I think what's also contributed to my whole depression and problems with feeding
was the midwife who scolded me on the first day. The first night after bub was born, I tried to bf him, I thought at that time I was doing it right. He also didnt sleep all night. I was up all night trying to calm him. I didnt know that I should/could call the midwife. The last midwife whose shift ended, said if you need anything the next shift will be on. No one came to see me or check on things and I didnt know that I should call them. Plus I hadnt slept since I had contractions on Wed, and this was Friday night. The next morning, I had just got out of bed and was trying to calm bub, and the midwife barged into my room and asked 'did you feed him well' I said he didnt feed very well. And she really had a go at me, abt not feeding bub, and if he gets into trouble, the midwives will get into trouble...
i was really in tears. when DH, and I was tears again &just then the pediatrian walked in. so we told him what happened. i think she was told but she was still very nazi like. if bub wasnt attaching, she'd violently shove him to my breast, and if i told her he was chomping, she'd say he's attached correctly and didnt want to know anymore.
then bub's weight fell below the allowed 10%, and because of that woman, I felt it was my fault cos I didnt bf him well the first night. BF went downhill after that, bub's tongue was on his palate and he didnt know how to attach properly and if he did, he would chomp on my nipples.
I really wanted to feed him, but it was getting worse and worse. i think every midwife at westmead had had their hands on my breasts!

anyway, im off bfing at the moment, expressing enough to relief the discomfort. But even expressing with an electric pump, my nipples are very painful. I hope the discomfort goes away, im a bit worried about mastitis.

I had a good sleep in this morning. 5hrs was luxury!
And this morning also, I looked at bub and toldl him I loved him.. DH reckons I;m getting more maternal. I think the relief of stress of bf and feeding him is allowing me to relax and to start to enjoy him..
Despite all the pain the last week and half, I really learnt how much DH loves me and his child. I never knew how much till now. I feel like the luckiest woman alive.

Anyway, that was my birth experience. Nothing prepared me for this..

Deleted

Prama I have breastfed all three of my bubs.

My first I almost gave up because it hurt so much! They were cracked and bleeding. Mason spewed up blood after one feed.

I persevered simply because I had so much milk that it seemed a shame not to. I used nipple shields and expressed to both rest my nipples and myself so DH could feed bub and I could nap.
I do remember the toe curling and the shooting pain still quite vividly but I took it one day at a time and the soreness seemed to get less intense. I thought I'd try a feed without a shield and to my surprise it was quite comfortable. By about 4 weeks we had come through it and Mason was even helping himself on and off! Feeding was a very nice experience from then on and he fed till he was 12 months.

My second, Angus, was a natural and I had no problems with him at all.

My third was a repeat of my experience with Mason and I found myself ready to throw it in when I developed an ulcer from a crack on the base of my nipple.
It was agonising and I was in tears but drawing on the memories of my previous breastfeeding journey I persevered and again used nipple shields and expressed to rest my nipple and we came through the other side around 3 weeks and went on to have a wonderful 15 months of breastfeeding.

Why I'm telling you all this is to share with you that it's not all easy. Many have faced pain and hurdles and come through it because it is a very beautiful and rewarding time.
I have spoken to so many mothers IRL and they express regret that they didn't persevere. If only they had the support to encourage them to keep going rather than switch to formula when it got hard. Be it from their mother or friends because that is what they did. I know I had both my mum and mil telling me to "put Mason on the bottle". Maybe I stuck it out to shut up mil ;)

I went to a tupperware party with my mothers group where I was the only one breastfeeding out of 5 and all of them said they wanted to but it was all too hard.

If breastfeeding is what you want to do then please by all means don't give up without trying everything you can. Express to keep up your supply and feed it to your bub rather than the formula. Contact the ABA for advice over the phone and hopefully a lactation consultant without delay.

If you want to do it then you can :hug: Keep the long term picture in your mind. It most definatley won't always be this hard. Don't forget you are still recovering from the birth and that in itself is hard enough!

And if you chose not to breastfeed your baby then that's alright too. Own your choice and be proud that you tried your best :hug:

ETA you posted while I was typing! No wonder you are feeling emotional. I honestly don't know why some go into the health care profession when they so lack compassion and caring. I'm glad to hear that you are feeling rested and better about the situation!

I didnt think anyone was promoting FF over BF. To me, it was sharing of experiences that made me feel better about myself and knowing I wasnt alone. And for my own sanity.

I know that BF is a wonderful experience that cannot be replicated by FF, that's what everyone says and that's what I've been trying so so hard to achieve.

God knows how much pain I've borne with such painful nipples. I dunno, to me the statement sounds like I havent borne the pain and switched to FF. I've switched to FF for now as a last resort. It wasnt my intention and I;m hoping to try BF again in a week. But at the moment, even the mildest expressing via the electric pump is so painful. I've rented the one that the hospital used, Ameda.
I'm sorry but that statement has upset me. Now, I'm back to feeling like I didnt try hard enough, and I feel guilty for switching to FF. I feel now like I cant do anything right, BF or FF......

p.s. i have seen a few Lactation Consultants at the hospital, spoken to my GP and the Early Childhood Centre. I've tried everything I know. Yesterday, I was finally told by the LC, for the same of my mental health and my baby's happiness to switch to formula.My GP told me the same thing on Thurs.
My milk never increased, I get 20-40ml only expressing both sides for 20mins.

Prama....:hug: I am gobsmacked and appalled and disgusted at those midwives! Argh! Really mad at them, I'm so sorry that you didn't have the attention and support you needed at such a crucial time.
No wonder things have been rocky!

I really think you need to complain - at some stage, perhaps it's not your focus now, but don't let this go unreported, it's not good enough.

That is so wonderful to hear that your relationship with your dh has been strengthened, and I'm so glad to hear that you're starting to connect with your bub - it takes different amounts of time for everyone, just a day at a time hon.

And still, I reckon, if you're able, keep expressing to keep the supply up, that will give you some room, and time for your nipples to heal a bit, and then you can take 2.
All the best. :hug:

ETA: No no Prama, I am totally getting from your posts how painful you found b/fing!! No doubting that!! (I wonder if it's possible that a manual pump is gentler than an electric one? I'm sure someone who knows these things will be able to say, but I vaguely remember conversations where people with electric pumps have been able to express far more quickly, which perhaps leads me to guess that a manual one might be gentler?)

ETAA: I know nothing of these things, but 20-40mls sounds enough? Like, my friend studying midwifery tells me that a nb's stomach is only the size of a walnut or something? (Once again, as the others have said, it certainly sounds like you're trying hard, and if formula is what you need to do, whether short term or for good, then there's no shame at ALL in that.)

Deleted

There was just that one midwife that was such a b!tch. The others were really wonderful and understanding. If anyone's at Westmead Private, I'll tell you who she is!
I am going to make an official complaint.

Nelle - I did order a manual pump from ebay. I'll try with that when I get it.

I'm going to go get a couple hrs sleep before it's time to feed bub again.

p.s. 1DH is adding his comment that all the LCs seem to say BF shouldnt hurt, maybe only for the first 60s, and then it shouldnt. But it looks like it hurts for quite a few women.

p.s.2 At this stage bub should be taking in 70mls. And the last few days my milk has turned almost watery and only at 10ml. I;m going to go see my GP and have a final chat with her.

Prama, please don't feel bad for using formula. You are doing what you needed to you. No-one thinks otherwise. Sushee's post was merely pointing out that you hadn't decided what to do going forward, and that given that your post was in the bfing support forum than you were probably wanting some support and advice about starting to bf again rather than just ffing testimonials. Whatever decision you make will be the right one, and you shouldn't feel bad. You can only do what's best for you at the time. You do have the option to start bfing again, and if that's what you want to do in your heart, than it is worth a shot so that you don't feel regret later. However, if all you feel is relief that the pain is over and you are comfortable with a decision to continue to ff, then that is your answer. Don't feel pressured, just give yourself time.

You have been through so much already. As I have said, I can totally relate to your difficult start to mothering. I too believe that DS's early arrival meant it took me longer to bond. He was born on the day before I was due to start maternity leave. I can also relate to the rough mws and lack of support. It is a really tough way to start your relationship with your new baby, and I think much needs to be changed in the whole obtetrics/midwifery world, but that is a bit OT. Just know that motherhood does get easier and does get more rewarding. You will get past this and be ok, but it's ok to feel as you do. Don't let that guilt get to you. You are doing a great job and you are a great mum. Hang in there.

Prama, watery milk just means that you are getting only the foremilk - you are probably not getting a let down. There is nothing wrong with your milk, you could still bf IF you want to. If this is the path you want to follow, I recommend a LC over a GP, you will get better advice and more gentle support. GL with whatever you decide.

:

---

My milk never increased, I get 20-40ml only expressing both sides for 20mins.

---

That is a perfect amount for a 2 week old bub. As Nelle said their stomach is only walnut sized. This is why they want to feed so frequently.

I believe the point that Sushee was making with her post was that this being in the breastfeeding support forum, and the way you had expressed that breastfeeding was what you wanted to do, that some of the comments seemed to be more of a positve promotion of formula feeding rather than supporting of someone having problems with breastfeeding.

As I said in my post before if you chose not to breastfeed your baby then that's alright too. Own your choice and be proud that you tried your best. Don't feel guilty :hug:

And in 20 mins, excellent! Riv was sooo sleepy and lazy those first few weeks, some feeds took 40 mins!! (though we fixed that eventually)
You could be doing better than you think!!

I second everything Sushee said about BFing.
For me, BFing was horrendous for the first 6 weeks, then not so horrendous for another 2 or 3 weeks until it 'just clicked', like all my BFing friends said it would.
Yes, I was angry that of all the useless things I was told when pregnant, not one person said that BFing could well be challenging and to stick with it. Luckily, I'm a stubborn cow and I did stick with it, and also luckily, once my friends knew I was having problems they were good enough to tell me that it does get better, if you persist with it. My anger subsided when I started to hear useful things like that!
The postscript is that I"m still BFing DS, and I even BF'd him on recent holidays to Ireland and the UK, where women who noticed took our BFing as their cue to 'confess' to me how much they liked their BF experience (BFing is not widely practiced in those places).
So, whatever you end up doing, if it IS BFing, rest assured there is plenty of support here and plenty of women who can share your experiences and help get you over the line :)

prama,

the post I made was not directed to you as such, but to everyone participating in this thread. I'm all for getting all information, and making an informed choice, ie pro-mum as I said before.

But as you posted in the BF section, I was surprised by the amount of posts from FFers saying that yes it's hard and that changing to FF may be the answer, but very few posts were actually from BFers saying that those first few weeks are hell, but damn it gets better, so much better, if you can stick it out. If you can, but if you can't, that's fair enough too. Yes no one tells you that it's hard at first, no one tells you that it's painful, and getting support can be so hard. Similarly no one tells you that if you stick it out, that it gets easier and easier, that those first few weeks are not typical of how it's going to be, that BFing is a skill you need to learn, just like riding a bike, where you fall and hurt yourself all the time, and most importantly, that there is a great benefit to your and your baby's well-being to be had at the end of it.

It concerned me that in a BFing support section, 80% are saying that the best decision they ever made was to move to formula. I then fear the message from BFers that it's bloody hard sometimes but worth it in the end tends to get lost. But what I'm not saying is that the benefit to your well-being now (less pain) is any more or any less important then the potential long term benefit of continuing to BF. Only you can make that decision.

But surely in the process of sharing our experiences, it's fair to put forth a balance of both opinions? A balance of both sorts of encouragement? But the way it was going, there were far more posts saying that switching to formula was the best ever decision (and I can quote them if you like) then opinions from BFers about the benefits of seeing it through. I did not make it FF vs BF, I did not attack FF to make BF seem superior, but I also don't wish the opinions of BFers being minimalised either, esp in this thread. The reverse would not have been tolerated in the FF sections, I promise you.

So I suppose my last post was more a gentle reminder as to which forum everyone was posting in, and the objective of the forum, than anything else. It's a BFing support forum designed to assist mothers who wish to continue BFing. It's not about your personal circumstance, prama, because as I've said before, no one doubts you're a good mother.

Deleted

The way I see it, if you're posting in here it's because you want some support and encouragement for the pursuit of BFing. You'll get that from me here! When I was having problems, in tears every night, bleeding and cracked nipples with blisters, oversupply and soggy sheets every nights, a baby who could barely attach to such huge boobs etc, I spoke to people who had BF. In fact, I spoke to my friends who had BFd beyond 12 months, more than once. Not one person I spoke to suggested that formula might solve my problems because they knew it wouldn't - I wanted to BF and I wanted BFing advice and support. It's not always possible to be surrounded by the support that I got, and I understand that. DP was my biggest supporter of all, too (he's not much chop in other areas where I need support, but he came through on this one!).
If you want a place where people are going to say you did the right thing by switching, there is a place here on BB for that and it's not in BF support. By that I'm not saying you didn't do the 'right thing', that's not my place to say, and I won't brook any misinterpretation of what I'm saying. Right here is where you'll get people like me who will say that it's possible to see past those very dark clouds and blindly pursue something that is so worth it, long term :)
I personally wouldn't have found it very helpful, during my time of need, to be told that it's ok to switch to formula. It wasn't what I needed and I probably would have bitten the head off anyone who said that to me.
If you feel BFing is important, come back and we'll tell you more about what we did to overcome 'horrendous' feeds in the middle of the night. If you don't, then please take heart in what other BB members have to tell you in other threads. Just please don't accept misinformation as support (eg formula is as good as breast milk etc), because if you're going to switch, you may as well know the truth about formula and what you can do to counteract the risks associated with it - sugarcoating the reality of formula only cheats you and your infant.
Regardless of which thread you post in, everybody wants the best for you and your baby, just remember that, ok? :hug:

:

---

Regardless of which thread you post in, everybody wants the best for you and your baby, just remember that, ok? :hug:

---

If you need a cheer squad, I'm right here baby. :p With all the encouragement I can give!

Really looking forward to hearing how you'll find the manual breastpump, by the way! Curious to know how you'll find they compare, I've never used an electric.
Hope you're having a really great sleep inbetween feeds. :)

I'm her to cheer you on as well. The support from this forum got me through my rough experience. If you can get through the next few weeks it will be sooo worth it.

Give the manual pump a try. It is so much gentler on the nipples. In the hospital they used an electric pump on me (when i was engorged and crying0 and I found it just as painful as breastfeeding. The manual pump though was fabulous.

I agree with the manual pump. You just can't vary the pressure on the electric ones any where near as well. I've got an Avent one. It's brilliant :D