Any comments on VB vs CS for breech baby?

HI - this may be a bit premature, but at 36 weeks my bubs is still breech and resisting moxibustion and inversions to help him/her move!

My OB said she is willing to do a VB if asked... I was with my sister when she gave birth to her first baby breech. It was a very long and exhausting labour and then she needed oxytocin and an episiotomy. I talked to her about whether she would have made the same choice, and she said she wasn't sure (even though she is very pro natural birth and had her second bub at home). She said she felt quite traumatised by the birth experience for some time afterward.

We whave decided with OB to try manual turning (ECV) at 37.5 week visit if needed. Bub is in an odd position - one leg straight up and the other down.

If that doesn't work we will need to make a decision at some point. My first thought was that I would try VB, but ultimately I want to do what is most safe for bub. I also am concerned with attempting a VB and then having to go for an emergency CS. I figure a planned CS would be less traumatic for everyone....

I really want a natural birth more than anything, no drugs etc. I have been preparing using the Pink Kit and going to weekly independant prenatal/birth education classes.

But then this bub is so precious I wouldn't forgive myself if something happenned to him/her during birth - and I know with breech there is more chance of cord prolapse and other risks to the baby.

Just wondering if anyone has thoughts on this?

BTW - I'm 37 and this is my first baby...

Personally, if I were you and I had an ob that was willing to do it, then I would go for it. Breech births aren't automatically more difficult than birthing a baby in a head down position, they are just another variation of normal. Do be aware though that your position during the birth is crucial to successfully birthing a breech baby, so you need to make sure that during your labour you are doing all you can to help yourself and your baby. If you go to www.spinningbabies.com there is a wealth of info there to help you. Also do you have an other support apart from your DH like a Doula? If you do you will benefit immensely from having one and her coaching you into the best positions. Also check out youtube for breech births as well to see that it can be done and also how it is done kwim? there is an independent midwife's website too that has a vaginal breech homebirth on it, I'll find the link for you.

ETA - here it is, Homebirth: Midwife Mutiny in South Australia

hi there

My first bub was breech, and we decided to have a c section. I wasnt very keen on the idea of an ECV, due to the risks for bub and myself, and a breech vaginal delivery sounded risky aswell. We were pretty much advised to have a c section delivery as soon as we knew out little boy was breech.

I just naturally thought i would have a vaginal birth, but when i founf out i had to have a c section it was a bit weird at first but because it was for the safest arrival of our little man we didnt think twice.

I had a no problems BF after the op - you often hear that its hard due to a sore belly but i fed normally in a normal BF position. Yes bubs is taken away, but this happens anyway doesnt it? My hubby was with bubs when he was taken away to be weighed etc and i was stitched up. Dont get me wrong, they hand bub to you as soon as they cut the cord and clean them up, we have great pics of us with bubs.

I had a pretty good recovery, the first nite is hard when you haev to rely on the midwife to get bubs up for a feed and change nappy etc. But i was up and walking the following morning and had my c section late afternoon.

At the end of the day its up to you & whats best for ur bub and youself - thought i would let you know a little about my experience with a caeasar deleivery. If you want to know more just let me know, i;m more than happy to share.

Thanks for those links Trillian - they are great.

If it were me, Numa, I personally would have to give the vaginal delivery a go, and then if it didn't work out in the end- then so be it. It may seem easier just to opt for a c/section and save dissapointment later- but truthfully, I think you would always wonder 'what if..?' - know what I mean?

I had a labour which spanned 4 days (I was determined to have my baby at home in water without drugs), but on the last day (at only 3cms dialated) I was too exhausted so opted to go to hospital to speed things up and ended up with an epidural, episiotomy, etc. I was disappointed that I didn't get the birth I had hoped for, but my saving grace was that I ended up with a vaginal delivery in the end. Looking back, it was the only aspect of the whole labour process that I was really happy with.
I know not everyone feels this way about vaginal delivery, but I just think that, no matter what your views on birth are- nothing should stop you from attempting to acheive the ideal. Just don't consider it a birth 'plan' - more of a birth preference. If you do not get your first preference- you can re-assess and take it from there.

My bub has recently turned, luckily, but she was a perfect frank breach before that.

And I was going for a VB. If you check the stats, (I did, lots!) A VB with a good positioned breach is still safer than a c-section.... not sure with one leg up and one down though... :lol:

There are lots of positions that are great for a breach birth, Trill has given you some great links...
Good luck with your decision babe, and bub just may turn yet!!!! ;)

i would try for the VB. esp if your ob is willing(so very few that are).
you will be in hospital so at any sign of a problem you will be c/sed straight away.
also going in to labour first is better for bubs then going straight for a c/s all the hormones help with bubs and your body in the aftermath of birth(either way)
there are some great books on delivering breech babies to so getting in to the idea of a slightly harder labour might help.
would you have your sister there with you?? i think she would be a great source of knowledge for you when you are in labour.

Have you seen this thread: https://www.bellybelly.com.au/forums...w-bisits.html?

:

---

... Yes bubs is taken away, but this happens anyway doesnt it?

---

Nope it doesnt always happen. With DS they did all the cord cutting, cleaning etc with him on my belly afterward. At and some hospitals they dont take them away after CS either.

If your OB is confident enough to do a VB surely she must think the babies positioning is OK, or else she will want the position to be a certain way for her to do it - did she say anything specific?

Thanks ladies for your posts!

Trillion thanks for the links, very interesting and useful

Bugalug for your story - was glad to hear you were fine with BF afterwards

Jellybean for your birth story - was your bub a breech too?

Purplemamma you have given me hope mine will still turn - do you have any links to stats? Everything I read didn't sound good for vaginal breech, so I would love to read something that indicates VB is safer than CS for breech.

Ellibam - good point about going into labour first and the benefits of the hormones, I hadn't thought of that..My sister won't be there but my Mum and DH will. Mum was also at her breech birth - mum is very instinctive and has very positive feelings about her own births, she'll be calm and reassuring.

Mantaray, thanks for the link, what an amazing guy hey!

Rayray, I must say I'm not totally sure where my OB is coming from. She discussed the study regarding safety of breech birth but then said the validity of it is questionable because most of the participating hospitals were in South America. She said she'll do a VB for breech if asked by parents because of risk of being sued if something goes wrong. I always get the impression she thinks I'm worrying far too much about things (probably true, but hey I'm a beginner!) and she seems very unfazed about everything.

I'm sure she is very skilled - she is the head of Maternal Fetal medical unit at Monash Medical Centre and used to be the president of RANZCOG - she would have seen it all and then some! I guess in the next appointment I'll go through all possible options and pros and cons for each with her.

Also at the hospital prenatal workshop the nurse said that the automatic CS for breech policy at Monash is changing, and they are starting to do more breech vaginal births again.

If anyone knows of any studies with statistics, other than the South American one, I'd love to read it!

:)

Kelly would probably have some more stats about that. If your ob is confident about you being sucessful despite all the info she has, I would still give it a good shot - I think you have a great support network in your Mum because she's BTDT with a breech baby of her own and knows that it can be done. But if baby is still high and can't engage because of the leg postitioning then that does bring in cord prolapse into the situation and that is a problem in itself. How far past dates is your ob willing to let you go? You might just need that little bit extra time to allow baby to turn too. Also, have you tried any acupuncture or Bowen Therapy to help baby to turn? Often babies can get 'stuck' because our stomach muscles are too tight so they tend to hold everything in better than someone on a subsequent pg. I really hope that bubs does turn around for you so you have a little less pressure and worry on your shoulders about it :hug: but I know that what ever you decide to do will be right for you.

Thanks Trillion :) . I think my post was a bit confusing - my sister was the one who had breech bub - she was full frank - I saw her cute lil bum come out first!

I have been doing moxibustion with my acupuncturist and also myself in between, I also see a osteopath regularly and she said there is nothing structurally that is affecting bubs position, she said my pelvis is great (haha!). I try to remember to do inversions and keep meaning to go swimming....

Your comment about tummy mucles being tight made me think about the mind/body connection, which made me remember that maybe I need to let go more - I can be a bit 'tight' mentally and try to plan for everything rather than trust in the process...

:D xx

I'm not too sure where my stats came from, maybe from Kelly!!! :lol: But with good position and no cord prolapse, the risk is very minimal... less than surgery...

But if bub is in a good position, and I was lucky she was for a while, and the middie or Ob know what they are doing, there isn't much more risk than a normal VB.

An ultrasound showed cord well out of the way, and bubbas butt planted firmly in my pelvis, so pretty much perfect position.....

She turned at 36+ 2 I think.... The main "exercise" I done was laying upside down on a slope.. you can lie on an ironing board, but i just layed with my butt on the lounge, and head on the carpet for just a little while, a few times a day...

Also letting her "swing".... knees on lounge, and hands on floor,(like your about to crawl off the lounge) so your tummy is "free swinging'

I believe doing both of these helped her unstick her butt and start to turn, and she was pretty deeply planted!!!!

So good luck for turning her, or good luck on getting the birth you want hon!!!! :D

Thanks Purplemamma :). I tried your way of doing inversions and it was good - hard to stay for long - but will keep trying to do them for short periods.

Am trying to stay hopeful....

How's it going numa?

numa, if you can, come along and see one of the BB Pregnancy Centre therapists, all the acupuncturists do pretty much is labour induction and breech babies!!! Check them out here: https://www.bellybelly.com.au/pregnancy-centre

The term breech study is majorly flawed. If you have an Ob experienced in breech birth then its much safer than an Ob who is not. They don't teach it these days and so they are scared to try it. Ironically, breech birth requires more of a hands off approach than more managed. If you can get your hands on Maggie Banks' book, Breech Birth Woman Wise, it's freaking awesome :)

Thanks for your posts SaraJane and Kelly, and to everyone previously...

I really struggled with this for quite a few weeks and have tried:

• acupuncture and moxibustion (have had regular acupuncture since started IVF). Did at least 2 weeks of moxa at home every day.
• regular osteopathic treatments
• inversions and a special yoga pose
• went to the pool and did handstands (admittedly only once)
• put my iPod headphones on my lower belly with nice music and also got DH to talk to bubs down there (I read that they may go towards the sound!)
• talking to my baby, explaining why it would be good to turn
• finally, last Friday, tried an ECV. OB could not get bubs bum out of my pelvis far enough to move.

I also did a lot of research and reading, a good bit of crying, and finally came to terms with having a CS. In the light of the support I've had in this thread I feel a bit like I've wimped out, but the thing that got me was that out of 16 different studies I read, 12 concluded that a CS was safer for the baby (ie less chance of death/injury). I just couldn't live with myself if anything went wrong.

Bearing in mind my bubs is not in a great position either (one leg up, one down), my age and fertility history, I just don't have the faith to attempt a VB. I noticed that Dr Andrew Bisits only does frank breech - if my bubs was full frank position I may have been more confident to have a go...I certainly don't want to try a normal delivery and then end up having an emergency CS.

So the end result is a planned CS at 39 weeks. OB said if I go into labour before my scheduled date and turn up to hospital and am 8 cm dilated, we'll go with it - so in this case I don't blame my OB for talking me into anything. Much as I grieve the birth I thought I would have, I have made this decision from talking to the people I know and trust - my DH, mum and sisters and also BB members.

And who knows, bubs may still surprise us yet.

Thanks again to all for your encouragement and support :).

Numa
:hug:
I know i sent you a message but just saw this post and had to come in and say choosing a CS is not wimping out AT ALL!!!!
You have made a totally educated decision that you can be very proud of and i just wish you all the very best.
I went through this whole process myself in regards to the Cs thankfully i had a bit longer to decide, but its been really really hard and the whole LTTTC and AC makes it so much more difficult than anyone could ever understand, at the end of the day we are use to handing are bodies over to doctors :doh:
You sound so positive and from the sound of it tried everything possible to turn bubs. I think you are going into your CS knowing there is no what if's which is the most important thing. Good luck next week and i cant wait to get on to see how you went !!!
P.S. I think its a boy :lol:

Thanks Scooby - looking forward to reading your birth announcement!

:) xx

numa, you are doing so well, you have done everything you can and have put a lot of effort into researching the best option for you. So you are making an informed decision and doing what's best for you and your baby. So proud of you!! :hug:

NOT WIMPING OUT AT ALL BABE!!!!

I have had three NVB and if i had a 4th buba and it was one leg up and one down i just dont know i would do..... it would be very hard to have the faith in my body.....and thats coming from someone who is VERY pro natural!

Enjoy those first few cuddles and that new born smell!!