Love them both but found the itti's were a little too narrow for my chubby bubba and looked a little like a g-string on here by about 12-15mth. Magicalls have much more coverage in the butt area but I have the older style and need to boost them if they are going to last more than a hour of two. Love my cuddles in cloth minkee slushies for minkee cuddles and have a great fit! Best naps for chubby bubs are ones with a double row of side snaps like berry plush and swaddlebees as it gives you individual leg and waist adjustments. Have fun shopping