We did the same thing with our five; I couldn't move past the losses, because it felt like I was the only one who considered them people. Now that they have names, no-one can ignore them.

Finley Elkanah
Devon Tekoah
Quinn Micaiah
Addison Shiloh
Caiden Azariah

Basically, I trawled baby name websites for names I felt were unisex and met our other rules (one biblical, one unusual). Then I put them in a list and went through them with Professor, and we both came up with the exact same names, no arguing, no disagreement, it just felt right