Would it be weird

[ameylynne]

To have two daughters named Elizabeth and Bethany?

[Chocaholic]

No, not weird at all. Elizabeth would probably get Liz or Lizzy as a nickname while Bethany will be Beth.

They are lovely names by the way.

[NaeNae]

No not weird at all ........ unless you already had two daughters names Elizabeth and Bethany

[boobaloo]

i think it's fine, and they're pretty names too!

[JordieC]

Personally I think they're too close. When you write them one after the other you write Beth twice. I know a family with a Stephanie and Stephen and that's too close too. But they are nice names.

[Santosha]

I think it really depends on what Elizabeth gets shortened to. If she gets Liz, Liza, Libby etc., that'd work fine, but if it's Beth... you might end up with 2 girls who get called the same thing.