I got mine at my baby shower some 18/19 months ago, its sort of a creamy colour, maybe pinky tinged but its so old now ITMS. I thought it was a little watery looking as opposed to grainy??

I guess thats the thing with these types of products the batches will all look a bit different despite the same contents, milk can be different depending on seasonal influences ... you'd notice tastes in the same product of milk differs slightly depending on seasons as grass can be richer or poorer, quality of grain or other feeds etc.

Check out the Moogoo website and see if they have altered the ingredients at all, but all in all, its a milk product, its natural so you'd expect to see some differences from time to time as opposed to getting the colour perfect like all the fake/synthetic/manmade products itms?

Nae x