I don't really want to get into a debate about debates. But if it were just members "asking" for new information I could understand. But often threads like this (and I am talking specifically about circ) turn into posts that bag out parents that have chosen to circ. Thats my point. And you may not agree and thats ok We are all allowed to agree to disagree, but from my perspective as a parent who circ's I think it goes past the point of being informative and becomes about who's right which isn't what the discussion needs to be about. I think once you've put your information forward great but why the need to continually argue your point? Especially when you are arguing with someone who will never be able to agree with you. See where I'm going?