Hee hee, Ryn - part of my consequences-style teaching is NOT turning lights on! The other week Oscar got fidgety in the middle of the night (ok, so he wasn't feeling 100% and was all over the place), I let him slip off the bed (he gets off surfaces feet first, something we learned in swimming lessons) and walk down the hall...in the dark. Maybe you missed that nuance, but I don't indulge him when we're not in synch, I just work with it and remember the words of my wise friend, Bathsheba, who says "This too shall pass" (she's in my head, dammit!).
Because I'm studying, too, if he is up at a stupid hour (which is rarely anymore - hard to believe that my 'system' can reap rewards, but it does!), I let him play and I'll read my textbooks if I'm awake enough. But then again, I do know that if he goes to sleep later, he'll sleep in longer, which is not something many other children do.
Like I said, you do what you gotta do. I'm not saying you do what I do (I made that disclaimer right at the start of my post), I'm saying you do what you gotta do that's right for you and your child. Even if I DID think less of you because you don't do what I do, who cares? Does it affect your life and what you think of your child? I hope not! No-one here can tell you what you need to do, and if they try then they're kidding themselves. All we can do here is tell you what we do with our own children so that if anything resonates as a possibility for you, then you can try it on for size.
For instance, I could have taken offence to you calling the non-sleepiness a 'malarky', cos I just work with that scenario instead of resenting it. Likewise, you might take offence to me calling myself a 'bunny' for stressing out over a non-sleepy kid. Neither of us mean to judge, we're just putting our slant on these things :) Chicken, I understand your frustration - this part doesn't last forever. Please don't wish away this time, either - you wish away the good bits when you wish for the less savoury parts (not sleeping, not eating etc) to be gone.
You'll get there, you know you will!

