We have a top loader however its a Fisher and Paykel Aquasmart - it doesn't have the spindle bit in the middle, so it kinda washes similar to a front loader IYKWIM - we use FL powder for it based on the manufacturers recommendation. I think we have the best of both worlds - we can easily add stuff in once started, and as its 8.5 kg its massive (can fit our king size quilt etc) and its nice and quiet. I'm also a bit paranoid with the accessability of opening a front loader to kids, whereas its so much harder and higher with a top loader

My Mum recently went from a top loader to a front loader and hates the damn thing with a passion, I think she plans to break it 'accidently' and go back to a top loader. She is really disappointed with the wash results - and she manages a laundry in a nursing home so she knows her washing!!