Would you take a toddler to a funeral?

[Tuesday's Child]

Not quite sure if this is the right spot for this, but here goes.

DH's grandmother died on Friday. It's his Dad's mum and he's not particularly close to his Dad's family. The funeral is Thursday which is normally a daycare day for DD (22 months). It will be a small funeral with only family and then a hotel lunch afterwards. It'd be good to take DD to see her family as we don't see them much. But it somehow doesn't seem appropriate, especially since we do have care arranged for her that day.

Would you take a toddler to a funeral?

[[M]umma[M]ia]

No, I dont take my almost 3 y.o to funerals. I dont think its appropriate and I dont want her seeing people all upset and not understanding why etc.

[shellbell3]

It depends for us, we take it as case by case thing, we did take the kids to FIL's funeral because they adored their grandpa.

[LoveKnowsNoBounds]

I wouldn't take DS to a funeral. I think it is scary for a little child and hard for them to see all the people they know out of control with their emotions (crying etc) when they aren't used to it. You could always pick her up after the service to take her to the wake. People are generally less upset there and she can see the family. Sorry for your loss.

[beansbeans!]

DD1 has been to 3 funerals, DD2 has been to 2.
The first was for our friends mum, DD1 was 8months.
The second they both went to and that was for their great-grandfather. DD1 was 2.5, DD2 was about 6months,
The third was for their cousin and they were about a month old than they were at the second funeral.

At all of the funerals they have attended they were really well behaved. Even though the funerals were at DD2's feed times. IMO I think that they 'know' whats going on. Their behavious changes and they seem to understand that everyone is sad, and its not the time to play up. That been said, DH and I have the agreement that one of use will take them out if we needed.
We've never regretted taking them to the funerals, and have never had second thoughts about it.
The funeral you are talking going to sounds like the same funeral we had for greatgrandfather, it was small and only family and close friends.

[Tuesday's Child]

You could always pick her up after the service to take her to the wake. People are generally less upset there and she can see the family.

That's what I'd like to do ideally. But the funeral is on the other side of town (an hour away) so it's not really practical to pick her up and head back for lunch.

DD is pretty good behaviour-wise. She'd pick up on the sombre vibe and would behave appropriately (at least until someone started playing with her). We took her to my mum's funeral but she was only 8 months old then. But I don't want to confuse her or her to feel upset because everyone else is upset and she won't know why. I'd expect that DH's cousin would bring her DD who is 13-14 months, but she was quite close to their Grandma.

If we do take DD it would be for our sakes and not for hers. That's what make it feel so wrong. On the other hand, I don't believe in shielding children from death either. I suspect DD understands a lot more than she lets on. She's so busy absorbing everything around her that it takes a while for it to come back out again.

[HotI]

I have taken my DD to 2 funerals (my grandfather and DHs grandmother). We had the agreement that if DD was unable to sit still at DH's family funeral then i would take her out and vice versa. I think you have to consider the personality of the child, and whether you and dh would be ok if you had to take your daughter out. Also, i guess the type of funeral, if there is potential for wailing or other things that kids might not understand i would probably be more reluctant.

The funeral that we went to that was smaller, mainly family, & followed by lunch at a restaurant was fine for DD to go to. She and i did walk around at the back of the chapel, but she was quiet and it didn't disturb anyone. Later, it was nice to have her there and to meet some family we don't see very often.

[feeb]

I went to a friends fathers funeral on fri and did NOT take my 2 boys (3 and 20 months) but she had her 3 kids there 4, nearly 3 and 7 weeks and another friend had a 2 year old there.
My friends 4 yr old was chatting away a bit and her 3 year old apparantly was being a bit of a pain but I did not hear either.

I knew that my 2 would be too loud and rowdy and I wanted to be able to give my friend and her family support without worrying about my kids.

[leckert]

If I was close to the relative who had passed I'd consider it (it'd also depend on child's temperament). But seeing as you've said DH isn't that close to person and you've got care booked I wouldn't take her.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk so sorry if I'm confusing you

[Lenny]

I took DS (3 months) to my neice's funeral. DH was there and walked out as soon as he made noise. I asked my Bro what their wishes were - they said they wanted ALL the family there. And their firneds had children too. It was all beautiful and at no point did i think anyone was too noisey or inappropriate.

When my grandad died, my very young cousins were there. My little cousin, 3, was baffled when the last post started and he looked around the whole church for the 'trumpet man'. Again, i never thought it was wrong and no-one was too loud. We just quietly chuckled when he wandered off. The little kids all brought grandad cards. It was fine.

When my aunt died my cousin brought his two young kids to the funeral. (19 months and 3) Unfortunately, they did not bring anyone with them to take the kids 'out' when they got impatient. They weren't noisey. but a little disruptive and it would have been nice at one point for them to have been taken outside for a little bit.

So, i think it pays to have someone there who is willing to walk out and miss the funeral in order to take the kids outside if they need it. Would you have a friend who would be happy to wait with you and help if you needed it? It would be a shame for you to miss the funeral. I think you should take her. That's just my opinion.

[Miss.September]

DD has been to two funerals. One was my grandmother and one was my great aunt. They both adored DD, so I felt it was fitting that she be there. I was a mess at my nan's funeral, when it got too much for me, DH took DD. She was fine, but in saying that, nan's funeral had a bit where all of her grandchildren took a teddy bear up to the casket (she loved bears and we'd all decorated one to go with her). DD was fascinated by all the different bears, kept her interested and quiet.

[Laranna]

We've taken ours to 2 funerals, DH's grandparents. Nobody minded, in fact we had a few comments that people were glad they were there. I personally don't think it's inappropriate as it's a part of life, but it's so individual and all families are different so it's really what you feel comfortable with.

[MummyNaomi]

DS has been to a funeral (not with us), but on the day Mum has him, her and her partner had a funeral of a family friend and wanted to go, Mum asked if I minded if she took DS (She was happy not to go if I wasn't happy with it) and I was fine. I was more worried about him being disruptive but Mum said he wasn't, and just seemed to 'understand' the mood and the surroundings. Towards the end when he got a little fidgety Mum's partner took him outside for some fresh air.
I've been to lots of funerals with kids - young and old! I agree with Laranna, its part of life and in most cases I think its appropriate, especially when the kids have been a part of the deceased persons life

[blackduckies]

I think it depends whose funeral it is..I would'nt just take them off to anyones funeral it would have to a family member or friend.
Our kids have been to several funerals family members & a close friends husband..I think for us it was important to honour their memory with the presence of our kids, they loved them and wanted to be around them..In life no one was worried about a bit noise and certainly if it was to the point of affecting other people we would be prepared to go outisde etc..
For us it would feel wrong NOT to take the kids.

[MrsC_Aussie]

hi, we took my 2.5yo and 4mo to my grandfathers funeral two weeks ago. My grandma really appreciated them being there, as did my mum. they are used to having to sit through church services though and so they were quite well behaved. personally I found it helpful to have my baby to hold on to whilst crying. I wouldn't take them to a non-family member's funeral though.

[forshelby]

Yes. I was the toddler, and nobody wanted me there from what I can gather. Least of all Mum. It was my Father's funeral. My sister and I were sent to a babysitter while the rest of the family (older brother and sister and cousins etc) all went to the service and said their goodbyes. I know I was only a baby, but it upsets me to know that I wasn't there to say goodbye to my own Dad.

- Just wanted to offer a different perspective.

For me, it would depend on my relationship with the deceased and their family. If we were close, I would check with them first and let them know I'm prepared to miss the service and take DS outside if he gets cranky. If I wasn't particularly close with the family, I probably wouldn't take DS. (he's only 6mths right now though, not a toddler).

[Astrolady]

We did when Andrew's grandmother passed. Had no choice really. Had to drive from Adelaide to Geelong for the funeral. Having said that though I can't actually remember him being there, but I know he was cause I can recall him being at the Cabins where we stayed and there would have been no one to look after him in the cabins on the day of the funeral. We however opted out of going to the actual burial. We just did the service.

[megs]

When my DH Nan passed away I was in a similar situation. It was also a Daycare day. So I went half way I put my 2 children in daycare for the morning, then after the service and burial I went and picked them up (had a change of clothes so they weren't in there daycare clothes) and then I brought them to the wake so family and friends could still see them.

Not sure if that is an option for you, luckily we live in a small town so everything is nearby.