The one that made me claustrophobic was a ring sling "parent's of invention" brand. I also borrowed a 'sleepy wrap' and i found this VERY comfy to use but it was hot and Archie didn't like being in it when he was awake. I could never swaddle him as a newborn and i think he just felt too squished... he was also a very hot baby and would sweat alot.

Blackrose: I also found the ring sling didn't feel "safe", like baby would tip out the side if you weren't careful! Maybe i wasn't using it right......