thread: GP=Mumbo Jumbo

  1. #1
    Registered User

    May 2008
    ...where jumping on the bed is mandatory!
    2,225

    GP=Mumbo Jumbo

    I have chosen to follow a gentler path with my DD, we co-slept for a while, but she went into her cot after a few months, (more a joint decision between Dd and I) i wore her for the first few months and still do 50% of the time now. I have chosen to demand feed, i dont use controled crying, i basically try to follow her as much as possible, on the few occations i have tried somethiing different, i soon realise it isnt for us.
    I am going back to the UK to visit my family and have told my Mum about the way i do things. Im used to the usuall comments about 'why im doing it that way' 'creating a rod' blah blah...but didnt expect it from my own mother!!

    I was talking to her about the amount of times id had to get up the night before to re-settle DD. And i got ''well, if you choose to stand there and hold her hand and tickle her back till she decides to go to sleep then your going to be tired, you should just let her cry when she wakes up, she'll soon get the idea. otherwise youl end up with a spoilt little brat'' they were her exact words....i couldnt belive it!!!!!!

    my dd is a happy, content little girl and im sure that some of that is just her nature....but id also like to think that some of it has to do with my hard work as a mother and the time i have put in to listen to and follow my babies needs!!

    I have no idea what im going to say to my mum, i was so shocked on the phone i just made my excuses and hung up. i dont want to argue with her but dont know how to explain my parenting choices with making it sound like 'mumbo jumbo' in her eyes! ( which is what she thinks the second i say the words 'gentle parenting') but the way i normally handle negative coments (its just the way i do things etc) just wont wash with her!!

    Anyone been in this situation or got and good definitons of GP or one liners that i could use!!!

  2. #2
    Registered User

    Feb 2008
    1,163

    I have not been in a similar situation as I have always had full support for the way I parent. I am sorry to hear of what you are having to contend with though.

    I guess the way you deal with it depends on the relationship you have with your mum. I personally would tell my mother clearly (perhaps before I left for the trip) that I fully respect her as a mum, I respect the things she did when she had young babies and the way she chose to parent. (Perhaps your mum is feeling that you are challenging her parenting skills in a misguided way). I would tell my mother that I am really happy with the decisions I have made about how I parent as they are well researched and well thought out. Sometimes I may need to vent, but that is all it is, a vent. Letting things out. I do not expect a solution to these vents necessarily but I do appreciate an ear to listen ! If this is not possible to do, this is fine, I will vent elsewhere (BB is great for that). I welcome advice and support of course, but I do not need negativity and dismissal of my parenting and my approaches.

    I would lay ground rule clearly but make sure mum understood it was not an attack on her parenting.

    However, I do understand that not all relationships work in a way where this would be effective. If your mother will not take this seriously, you could either stock up on info and shoot out evidence for all of your approaches. Try googling "attachment parenting confidence" to prove how attending to your child's needs is important to developing their self-esteem and self confidence. But this does sound like a pretty exhausting way to spend your time visiting your mum.

    The basic principles of attachment parenting result in parents being responsive to a baby’s needs. Parents who respond to baby’s cries and hold a baby frequently are fostering self-esteem in the child. The baby quickly learns that his needs are important and that he will be cared for and loved by his parents.

    How a parent interacts with a baby also helps lay the foundation for a healthy self-esteem. Parents should react with kindness and compassion to a baby’s negative emotions, like fear, anger and sadness. Likewise, sharing in the baby’s discoveries and joys teaches the baby that he is important and likeable.

    Read more: "Building a Child's Self-Esteem: Attachment Parenting, Childhood Accomplishments & Unconditional Love | Suite101.com"
    If it comes down to it, I would simply say,

    my dd is a happy, content little girl and im sure that some of that is just her nature....but id also like to think that some of it has to do with my hard work as a mother and the time i have put in to listen to and follow my babies needs!!
    As well as : I am very happy with the way I am doing things mum

    FWIW, I think you sound as if you are doing a really great job, and a happy baby is all the proof you really need!

    ETA: Spoilt little brats are not a direct result of responding to your child's needs.
    Last edited by jackrose; May 9th, 2009 at 02:15 PM.

  3. #3
    Registered User
    Add Marlene on Facebook

    Jul 2007
    Dapto, Illawarra...NSW
    2,009

    I know how you are feeling, I get this reaction to gentle parenting from my own husband. I haven't been able to change his mind, and his narky comments usually end up with me saying something like "I'll do it how I want, You're not the one who gets up in the middle of the night so shut the hell up" LOL. I wouldn't recommend speaking to your mum like this though, hehehe.