I have the Covergirl "best mascara in the world" stuff, in the pink tube with green lid, and it is AWFUL! In my opinion. Because it is very... thin? And a tiny brush. I use it now because my Avon one has pretty much run out.

I loved my Mabellyne (sp!), Wondercurl, but they don't make it any more. Anyone know what is most like it?

I also think the Avon Supershock is pretty wonderful. Available in black, or dark brown (ps, I know Avon have other colours too). It has a nice big brush, and is really thick. It doesn't irritate me after a long day.

Glad your eyes are on the mend, I'd be heartbroken if I had to throw $300 of anything out!