My pick of your names would be Hayley Renae but here are a few more to throw in the mix....

Sienna Renae
Amelia Renae
Maddison Renae
Lisa Renae
Caitlin Renae
Bethany Renae
Darcy Renae
Kaylee Renae
Thea Renae

Good luck with it all. We too are undecided on a girls name (we don't know what we're having though) so I know how you feel! I'm sure the perfect name will pop out at you before you know it.