Fairly conservative but not overly popular girls names

[Mrs P]

I like Caitlyn. DH always liked Lexi and I do too except it rhymes with se*y ha ha! That just makes it too easy for school kids to tease. Love Alexis too.

Our DD is L.iana M.ay - biased but I love it as its uncommon but very normal and easy to spell. And its very pretty. Have only ever come across one other and that was after she was born (and was an older lady). I think it goes well with Ann/Anne.

[Kazzo]

DD2 is M@cey, that is my pick from your list I think Isabelle you will find popular, out of your list it is the only one where I know quite a few little girls with that name. I have a soft spot for Gabrielle too but, I have a cousin with this name but so many people get her name wrong and call her Gabriella because it is the feminine version.