we had the same drama and named our dd Kim.ber.ley. I don't come across it often with girls her age..

From your original list, my DD has Alexis, Gabrielle, Isabelle x 2, Caitlin, Madeline, Charlotte & Mikayla in her class at prep this year.

ETA I loved most of the names already listed in this thread, but we either had friends, or family, or a pet with those names..