Heres my shortlist of girls names from your suggestions, what do you think?

[Kitt3n]

I love Melody!

[Snacks]

LOL, I hope this thread wasn't supposed to help you narrow it down!!!
I really like Amelia, Sophia and Eden.

[Aimz]

Amelia Rose Jenner
Amelia Jenner
Oliver, Gracie & Amelia
Amelia ? German - Worker beloved, industrious, striving
(Milly nickname)

I LOVE LOVE LOVE this one. Amelia goes so well with your other children's names and Milly is just so gorgeous for a nick name. My friend has a "Millie Rose" and she is so beautiful! I don't think it matters that your friend has a baby with the same name - it's YOUR baby you need to think about.

Summer is really pretty but perhaps just a tad too literal when paired with Rose.

My second favourite is Sophia.

[Kazmar]

Annabelle

The only reason I think this and why I called my princess this is because its a known name but I dont know any and there's never another one when you walk into a room or go somewhere. Not to different, classy, pretty and a beautiful meaning

[DaintreeDream]

I like Amelia Rose, very pretty.

I have always like the name Sarah also, however it depends if you want a 'normal' name or something a bit different.

I love Eden, but.... for a boy.... sorry .

Deanne.

[Kazmar]

I agree The Edens I know are boys

[Beckibee]

I agree The Edens I know are boys

I'm the opposite, I know one Eden and she's a dancer.

[lilcosmo]

I think Summer Rose is gorgeous. It goes beautifully with Oliver & Gracie too, BUT, I think 'Summer Jenner' sounds a bit funny IMO.

Out of your list my fave is Amelia, it goes really well with Jenner and Oliver & Gracie! Like sneakysparkle said, I wouldn't be worried about your mothersgroup friend.

Sophia is my second fave.

Good luck deciding.... its so hard isn't it!!

[Mum0809]

I love Tahlia & Sarah.

[smiles4u]

I quite like Summer Rose ... i actually think it truely does fit in with your other children's names

I love SOPHIA ROSE JENNER

... And yes, ' Kass ' is so right about Annabelle's ... have hear the name yet never met an Annabelle ... such a beautiful name (& so easy to spell which i love) & Annabelle suits a lil girl, a teenager, a young woman & elderly lady (my Mum always taught me that about names to suit all ages of a females live ) ... Ah, but there can only ever be one ' Bella Ballerina ' (Kass knows that)

[summerluven]

I love love love Summer, but as already mentioned, I am not sure if it flows with Jenner. I am sitting here saying it over and over again. Hmmm, not fatal. If you love it, go for it.

And I totally adore Eden. I have that on my list if I have DS2 but I think its a unisex name.

You have some lovely names here. Good luck!