Thank you all so much for all this helpful feedback! You ladies are fabulous! Please keep them coming.

Feueriosa - We do seem to have very similar taste in names. Some of your suggestions were on my original (much longer) list.... and I just mentioned Carys to DH this very morning as a possible middle name as he loves names with a Celtic/Gaelic history (hence why he likes Eilish so much I think!)

sneakysparkle - Evangeline and Arabella are also on my original list (I was too hesitant to post the full list earlier as it is a bit long!). My concern is that Evangeline is getting too popular - though I guess that can be said for some of my other names too!

Nai - hmm, I really do like those nicknames for Genevieve also. argh... what to do, what to do?! And I like Imogen Annabelle, but I think that could be quite a mouthful???

Anyway, please keep the feedback coming... it's very helpful! And any middle name ideas would be great... particularly for Imogen which I am still favouring... i think!

My only other dilemma is that my DS has 2 middle names, so part of me thinks that my DD should also... however, I tend to like longer names for girls and it could be quite a mouthful.

Why is this so hard?!