I would usually say traditional. I am a pretty traditional kinda girl. My first two children have traditional names, spelling and all- Lily, and Liam. But with #3 we just could not agree on a name until we came across the name Caelan. Not a totally unusual, out there name, but definately not traditional.
I say if it tickles your fancy, use it. Traditional or not, it's up to you and if you like it, why not??