What a lovely name, I totally understand! My sons name is 'Talan' so we are having the same trouble trying to find a second name for the next bubs!

Not really fitting with Mateo - but what about 'West' or 'Ryder'

I just googled some Spanish/Italian names for ides!
* Benito
* Ismael
* Javier
* Juan
* Pascual
* Roman
* Tadeo
* Cappi
* Dante