And the tantrums continue....

[Marley&Me]

I am still having dinner time tantrums almost every night. DD doesn't want what I give her, just screams for 'bicky' etc. I leave what I give her on the table if she won't eat and go about my own thing. She will just scream and scream and scream. Her screams are ear piercing. My head is throbbing. This can continue for up to an hour some nights. Sometimes she will eventually eat half of it, but mostly she will eat less than half and sulk through the entire thing. She is 20 months old. I have tried adding cheese, making it fun, eating it with her etc. It just seems she doesn't learn that she eats what she is given or nothing. When she does eat it, I praise her and tel her good job and then she will get some yoghurt or the likes after. Please tell me this is completely normal!

[beansbeans!]

Fortunately or unfortunately your place at dinner time sounds very similar to mine in the past. Dd1 was a shocker of an eater at that age, refused absolutely everything, screamed, whinged, threw her food etc every night. And to make it harder she wasn't consistent in her tastes as well. Dd2 did the same.
There is some hope, it got better with time. But I was persistent and consistent.

Have you tried changing her dinner time? It's amazing what a difference that can make

[Marley&Me]

Thanks beansbeans! Yes i pushed it a bit later so she would be more hungry I guess if her screaming wasn't so loud and high pitched it wouldn't be so bad haha.

[Lily Dust]

Is it normal? Hell yes!!!! Well, it is my house too DS is 22 months and the squeals he is making at the moment make my ears want to bleed! He also refuses any form of dinner but unlike your daughter he won't say a stinkin' word he just hits his buckle and screams to get out of his highchair. He also likes to throw his cutlery and food across the table at me Honestly, I've given up. We eat and then get him out. It's frustrating but I guess, like everything, it shall pass. Yanno, like the no sleep, sore boobs, not listening, grubby hand prints etc

[Marley&Me]

Argh! It's so frustrating isn't it? From the moment I put her in the car after picking her up from daycare she starts I'm lucky to have a few minutes of happy time before she cracks it. Then it just gets worse when we get home. If I stay out of the kitchen and play with her she is a bit better, but we all have to eat! I cook easy stuff on work nights so I only need 10 minutes or so to myself to cook. I could see how tempting it could be to just feed your kids crap to keep them happy. But I just can't do that!
Spag bog tonight, I'm cooking it now so all I have to do is cook some pasta when I get home tonight. She usually likes it so fingers crossed

[CoNNiE_Melb]

Is she in daycare full time? We generally don't have this issue, but DS2 is at daycare 2 days a week and on those nights he is definitely a handful and I tend to give him dinner about half an hour early than usual. If he is whinging and not eating, then I just get him out and get him ready for bedtime - which is also half an hour earlier on those nights.
I don't stress too much if he doesn't have a big dinner, because I know he'll make up for it the next day.

Not sure if any of that applies to you or would help, but just thought I'd share our experiences

Just she eat well during the day? Is it only dinner that's an issue?

[HotI]

if we do late dinner, my kids are less likely to eat. if possible, try an earlier time.

(no guarantees, but sometimes it is nice to have something else to try)

[Marley&Me]

Is she in daycare full time? We generally don't have this issue, but DS2 is at daycare 2 days a week and on those nights he is definitely a handful and I tend to give him dinner about half an hour early than usual. If he is whinging and not eating, then I just get him out and get him ready for bedtime - which is also half an hour earlier on those nights.
I don't stress too much if he doesn't have a big dinner, because I know he'll make up for it the next day.

Not sure if any of that applies to you or would help, but just thought I'd share our experiences

Just she eat well during the day? Is it only dinner that's an issue?

She is in 4 days a week. The ladies tell me that she eats very well at daycare so at least she's got food in her tummy. I actually brought her dinner time back half an hour because that's what time I get in the door anyway. And yes it's only dinner that is an issue. But she tends to graze all day usually, fruit, sandwich, crumpets, etc. But i like to give her a bowl of food for dinner instead of just snack food. Maybe that's why she cracks it? But daycare always do dinner style meals for lunch and she eats them.
It feels like she just hates being home and wants to be at daycare instead of home with me

[Arimeh]

Ds2 is 18 months and lasts for about 2 minutes and then climbs down from the table. He then goes for his bath - even with 4 other kids at the table he doesn't stay, we don't make him eat or make him stay, he just goes for his bath and then has his bottle. I'd say its pretty normal - I fight more with the girls (6, 5 and 4) to eat than with him lol

[CoNNiE_Melb]

It feels like she just hates being home and wants to be at daycare instead of home with me

Oh hun, I can imagine it would feel like that sometimes, but I can bet my house on that not being the case!

She may just not be hungry. Or maybe she prefers to have her big meal/ dinner type meal at lunch?
Childcare nights we generally just do sandwiches or something simple because they've already had their big meal at childcare.

I think for now, just do whatever gets you all through with minimal screaming and frustration. It's most likely a phase that will pass. At the moment dinner time is just a really stressful time for all of you, just wing it and release the pressure valve for a little bit. When you think she's ready, just casually try to reintroduce proper dinners, if it doesn't work out, leave it and try again at a later date. As long as she's getting good food into her during the day, she'll be ok.

[Saffy]

Hi Tasha, my DD doesn't go to daycare and she has dinner tantrums too.
I moved it later which helped a bit, also try to get something ready early in the day so I just have to put in the oven later, but not always possible. I also make sure she has a savoury afternoon tea (she's a sweet tooth and would eat crap all day if she was allowed)
She even cracks it when I am preparing dinner early and yells 'no deedee, no deedee!', even if it's 11am!!
Hate to say it but it's also progressed to 'no bath or shower' and pretty much no anything if she is in a bad mood lol.
I just try and go with the flow, but easier said than done, it's COMPLETELY frustrating.

If she is having a 'meal' for lunch, maybe just give her a 'tasting plate' for dinner, little bit of carb, little bit of veg/fruit, little bit of meat, then she can have some control over what she eats. Alternatively, just do what I do when I am desperate and give her a bowl of plain pasta lol

[Frangipani Lou]

It will pass. If she eats well at daycare she may only need some crackers/ a sandwich and some yoghurt with muesli. If it's not working then perhaps a more gentle approach may help. Perhaps also consider thinking through the impact on your relationship together. She may also be tired and need to play and reconnect with you after not seeing you (and most likely missing you) all day.
The goal is for you both not to get stressed and upset and for her to have something nutrition to get her through the night. It's also about(imho) not creating issues around food and also respecting her right to say no.
We got through this period by offering what we were having(and eating with her) followed by fruit, yoghurt and muesli which is all nutritious and filling. In our family, second course is another opportunity for good nutrients and energy essential for a balanced diet and not as a reward for eating first course.
Remember toddlers like to graze. We use a mental lunchbox called Lunch Bots and I fill it with something from each food group for her to snack on.
Remember it's our job to offer a wide variety of foods and their job to decide how much to eat of it.
Good luck!

[Frangipani Lou]

I used to put DD in her high chAir in the kitchen and give her tastes of the things I was cooking, including raw veg. Now she's addicted to raw veg and she was safe and happy in her high chair.

[Marley&Me]

I have realised that dd is a grazer. She prefers to snack all day long rather than have big meals. So now I just keep giving her snacks every couple of hours or as she asks. But I do try and put a small bowl of vege or the likes before the snacks at dinner/lunch. Her snacks are generally pretty healthy. things like dates, sultanas, fruit, rice cakes with vegemite etc.

So that's what has been working for us. I tried to giver her a bowl of homemade minestrone soup last night and she was already tired and cranky, so she threw it all over the floor! Was not happy!

[Andie78]

oh, no, tasha... minestrone is so hard to clean off the floor too... so many chunks!

I was looking for this thread yesterday actually, ds has suddenly turned. he used to eat everything, and easily. now he will not sit still in his highchair, standing, twisting around. eats 2-3 mouthfuls then it's 'no. no'. it's quite a shock bc dinner is something he's always eaten. lunch is always hit & miss but like your dd, tasha - he's a snacker throughout the day. he's had a cold & is still snotty atm, so I know that's part of it. but it's not the whole reason. I think he's discovering his voice, and how to use it! I worry with him though bc he doesn't have the weight to lose with bouts of not eating (been going on for over a week now), and he's lost the fullness in his cheeks already. I hope he gets back in track soon. :-/