I was given some advise by my HCN the other day, who said to one at a time, cut a little of the tip off the top of the dummy. This will eventually annoy them more than satisfy them, and they will throw it away themselves.
I haven't tried it yet, as DS is due in July and I don't want her to be unsettled when I'm up all night with him, so I'm going to try when she is about 1&1/2. So I don't know if it works, but I guess you have nothing to loose, except a dummy!!!
we got rid of Madisons dummy around the age of 2, We just gave her a choise one day ( after she had been having it all the time) to either put it into her bed or put intot he bin, she put into the bin and that was it, When she asked for it, we just told her that it is the bin, she winged for it for one night.
Bookmarks