Jenna was still being wrapped then!! So we didn't have fidgety finger problems. But now she can take anything to bedshe likes. Often a small book, the latest is a soft banana in pyjamas keyring. Totally wierd, but she likes it so who am I to complain!
Once she stopped being wrapped we used to give her an extra dummy to hold on to which she loved. But if you dont use dummies?? I think a little cuddle toy would be fine at this age?