CC is CC no matter how you dress it. But you know what if you're comfortable with that great. Doesn't mean you're evil and should be burnt at the stake but just like anything else its not for everyone.

We tried CC with Paris and it was a nightmare, no I didn't look at the clock but it was still CC. I'm ok with that, I realise now how ineffective it was for my children and as a result we did things differently with Seth. We chose the comfort path, but even then he wasn't interested in being held or rocked to sleep he wanted to be comforted in his bed. So thats what we did and it worked for us, yes we had bad days but everyone does and he is a lot more settled at sleep time now than Paris was at this age.

Some kids sleep some kids don't. Sometimes there is a magic answer and sometimes you just have to work with what you've got.