Ok - so we've finally decided. We're going to get the Weber Genesis, yes it's expensive (of course it is as it's made in the USA) and was over our budget but DH got a nice little bonus in his last pay so we're going to splurge a little. It is solid as a rock, has a great warranty and great features. To us we just think it's worth the extra compared to other brands and everyone that I've spoken to that owns one loves it. So there you have it - decision made!

Thanks to everyone for their input!