I have been out of high school for 13 years now, but in my experiance it's not where you get your education, it's what you do with it. I know alot of people that went to either the public HS and I would say 80% are doing alot better in career and life in general than those who went to the private HS here.
I will be sending my kids to public primary and secondary schools for sure.
Good luck with your decision.