Which would you choose - the 'best' school (at a cost) or a better lifestyle?

[Santosha]

I am completely smitten with our local Steiner school and really, really want to send my kids there. It's got everything I could ask to give them the most ethical, nurturing and inspiring education. Problem is, the fees are private. Starts at 6k a year, and goes up from there.

We're really struggling on one income ATM, but we get by with the basics and just manage the mortgage. There's no way we could afford the school fees unless I go back to work full time (or almost full time).

I'm currently looking at enrolment (kids are still little but you have to get in really early) and am basically weighing up this:

A) Send them there. Means that for 5 days a week they will have what I consider to be the best environment for their emotional, social and spiritual development. BUT... Mummy won't be around as much and will be more inclined to be more frazzled when she is. We won't have the extra money for holidays, activities or to maybe upgrade our home one day.

B) Just go local public school. Still looks pretty good, just not my 'ideal' IYKWIM. Mummy around more, and more cash for a nicer lifestyle.

Sorry... 'Mummy' is frazzled as it is, so hope that's not too garbled.

What would you choose? Or have you already have to make this choice and how did you come to your decision... and is it working for you?

[Cassius2]

It would really depend on what the next best option is IYKWIM.

From my perspective: there is a very real chance that, with your guidance and parenting approach that your children, even without the steiner school, will have access to ethical, nuturing and inspiring education. Having you around a bit more will help compensate for a little less immersion in the school environment. having the extra finances is, a necessary component in helping to create a more harmonious home (money stress can be really hurtful on a wholistic level IYKWIM).

that said, if the public school that is the next best option, is in fact, not the best option for your child, then it may be worth the sacrifice of time (yours) and money. For example, if there is a real possibilty that your child might not cope at all within the public school environment (and may suffer for it), then the answer is clear. Children still get a fulfilling life and love from parents that work full-time. and if this creates the necessary harmony and aspiration of dreams in your home, then it is worth it.

It is not an easy decision

All in all, whatever you decide, your child will be surrounded with love and be given all the best opportunities for life fulfillment: something that is not necessary only acheived by where they get there school education.

Goodluck with this decision xx

[wysiwyg]

From my perspective: there is a very real chance that, with your guidance and parenting approach that your children, even without the steiner school, will have access to ethical, nuturing and inspiring education. Having you around a bit more will help compensate for a little less immersion in the school environment. having the extra finances is, a necessary component in helping to create a more harmonious home (money stress can be really hurtful on a wholistic level IYKWIM).

Totally agreed - Personally I would go for option B, because I would want the time and the finances to be involved personally as much as I could in their development. Also schools change over time even Steiner schools so personally I wouldn't want to invest that 'heavily' in a school. My brothers girlfriend went to a few Steiner schools as a child and didn't always have the best time, seems there was a certain rigidity in their methods which didn't always suit her. I suppose what I am trying to say is you can't predict exactly what your children will be like and what will suit them as individuals (My cousin sent her DD to a private grammar school for her kindy year with the intention of her staying there, but the way enrollments went and people leaving she was the only girl in the class and would have continued to be, and started to really dislike it, so has now started at her local catholic school instead) so I wouldn't want to choose a specific school if it was to the detriment of other things because you just don't know what the school will be like in 8 years say or what your kids will be like - but you know that you as a parent will be able to be flexible to meet their needs and assist in their development - so I would want to keep the time and the finances for that.

[MrsFabuloso]

A better life style. You could provide alot of other learning opportunities for that amount of money per year (and much MUCH less!), plus they get the added bonus of having you around and you being happier. Whilst life is about trying to provide your children the best things in life, it also needs to be balanced. You need to think of you too. If you're going to be frazzled and tired alot of the time, and the kids won't be getting the best of you because of you trying to give them their education, as a child, I know what I would much rather have- my mum happy and nurturing me rather than in a hurry and frazzled because there isn't enough time int he day for her. I'm sure you and your DH could teach them many similar lessons and if you live the kids of lifestyle you aim for, then they will learn that way.

[Astrid]

Better lifestyle - well not really that, more secure financial future. We are behind the 8 ball here and trying to catch up the best we can. We have lived on the edge and it is not fun. We would like to be able to take the children just on simple holidays to visit family. We want to have financially stable (mortgage paid off, money in the bank) by the time they hit uni age, as that is where we feel they will probably need the greatest level of financial support from us.

Sometimes it is not just a matter of the now, or the next few year, but 15+ years down the track. We always need to keep that future in mind.

[Santosha]

Thankyou all so much for your thoughtful replies. It's given me a great deal to think about. TBH, I was surprised that the majority lean toward option B, mainly because I think I have generally been tending toward option A.

My argument to myself is that school is the place that they will spend the majority of their days throughout their childhood, and so the culture in which they are immersed is bound to have a huge impact on their imagination, intellect, relationships etc. DH and I will be who we will be. Yes, having to stretch ourselves financially and time-wise will leave us 'frazzled', as I put it, but I hope that we will still maintain our ethics and parenting style. A house is just a house, and whilst we may never afford a bigger one, this one will meet our children's basic needs. And there's nothing wrong with camping rather than trips to far-off places.

Reading your other ideas has given me pause to consider 'B' more though. Obviously, I was thinking about it, as I wrote this post, but I don't think I really considered the many valid points you have made. Fortunately, I have a while to make the ultimate decision and will then know more about what our budget looks like when I return to work.

I think if it was just a matter of private versus public school, I would have a clear preference for the local public school, especially for primary. I went to a mainstream private school and don't think it afforded me any great advantages, except perhaps for the final couple of years. In fact, the culture of the school really didn't suit who I was and I found it stifling and in many ways, quite damaging. The confusion really comes from my love of the Steiner ethic and culture. It's just an aside... a really big, expensive one, that the fees are what they are. I'm more than happy to accept that Steiner education may not suit my children's personalities and learning needs and will try and be as responsive to what suits them as possible. But in the mean time I have to make a decision based on what I hope might be best for them, and i really feel like this school might have 'it'.

Ginger... and someone else who asked (??!!), the school has long waiting lists and esentially I'd have to start from primary to ensure that they'd have a place. I understand that it's next-to impossible to get a place in the senior school without having been in the primary. I think that the Steiner style of education really suits young children and how I want their childhoods to be 'shaped'. I would have to re-assess when they're heading for secondary school as of course it would then depend on what they want in terms of academics, structure, subjects and teaching style.

Ummm... sorry, so utterly brain-dead, I'm not sure if I've covered everyone's comments and queries. Thanks again ladies. Lots to think about. xoxo

[LuluHB]

Its such a tough one. My girls are at a private school now - kindy and pre-primary, and it is a struggle for us to pay two sets of fees on a single income but the private school is a kazillion times better than the local public primary schools. We moved to thsi area a couple of years ago and it was something we factored into our decision - had we stayed in our old house the girls would have gone to the local public school. I will be home with our new baby for a few years (we have agreed that is the right thing for our family), so things are going to be very tight. When DD3 starts kindy there is no way I won't be having to work - just to keep the fees up for the three of them.

I do think we have all become more materialistic and perhaps unreasonable in our views of what we "need" to have a good life. Time at home with your family when you're not shattered from work is a different issue though. Is it possible to send them to the public school to begin with, and then the Steiner school later? In your position, if you think the public school is still good then I would be inclined to try that out first. If you have issues, or when your kids are older, then you can reassess.

[krysalyss]

I would go with the normal school for sure. There is no way we could afford those fees for one let alone more than one child.

[~ Mylitta ~]

I'm in the same dilemma. I have my heart set of a private school half an hours drive away. Luckily the fees aren't quite as high as the school you are looking at, but now I have to factor in three kiddies, not just two (fingers crossed they have a good sibling discount!). I've already done the "pre-enrollment" paperwork for Kyson to put him on the waiting list so hopefully he gets in.

I guess my main concern when it comes to deciding between a school I think will be really good for them and the financial hardship, is the fact that they are going to be spending soooooooooooo much time at the school. I mean 9-3.30ish, 5 days a week is a huge amount of time, so the environment and basically the entire schooling system is going to have a huge affect on how my kids learn and grow. It's for that reason that I am inclined to bite the bullet and go with the more expensive school that is further away from us, rather than any one of the 5-6 public schools within a 10 minute walk/drive from our house.

Oh, I forgot to mention that the school I'm looking at goes from pre-prep through to year 12, so I have already been looking at outcomes for the senior schools in the area, and this particular school I want to send them to has a really large and varied range of subjects offered in year 11 and 12 (the public school seemed to be quite limited around here), and it also has one of the highest average year 12 scores for not only this area, but in general. I feel really strongly about how important those final two years are even though Kyson's only 2yrs9mths and one bub is not even born yet, lol!!!

[Phteven]

We've always chosen lifestyle over private school.
For the cost of a decent private school we can afford to take our children overseas once a year and IMO they will learn more from travelling the world than they will in school.
We moved into area for an awesome public school so we could get the best of both worlds - a great school and no school fees.

[Ginger]

would they go to the steiner school right through to year 12 or is it just for primary school?

[RockingBaker]

I'm opting for public school and a better lifestyle for my kids. I'm researching schools now so I have ample time to move into my chosen schools catchment zone.

[black_rose]

It's such a hard decision, but I think if you are going to scramble for the money you arent going to be a happy mummy or daddy. We fell in love with one of the private schools too but just cant justify the cost with three kids.

[Traveller]

We have chosen lifestyle over private school. There is an awesome private school near us but it is so expensive, if I was working full time it would take all of my income to pay fees. We would rather use that money for holidays and other experiences that they can learn from. However this decision is influenced by the availability of other good schools in the vicinity of our house and if there was absolutely no other school nearby that could help our children have a great education then we could change our minds.

[Amity]

For me, I'm choosing a fabulous (out of area enrollment) local government school for primary, but my children will go to private secondary schools.

I will take three jobs, cash in my super and even sell my house if necessary to fund their private secondary schooling.

This is how strongly I believe in private secondary schools.

I live in Melbourne and I believe that has a huge influence on whether or not private schools are necessary.

I'm in my mid 30s and still get asked what school I went to. It still influences people's perceptions of me as a person. Sure it shouldn't be that way, but it is.

And that's my personal choice. I'm going to have to find $50K per annum (after tax) to fund the private schooling. I'm single, but lucky enough to (probably) earn enough to make it happen. Their father has already indicated he will not be contributing at all to private school fees.

So I'll be sacrificing lifestyle for secondary schooling. I probably wouldn't do it for primary though. Again that's choice - in primary years I'd choose lifestyle because I can teach them more at home.

[nothing2lose]

I have always believed that education is one of the few things that no one can ever take away from you.

I think we should try to provide the best education we can for our kids.

That's not to say that private is necessarily "the best".

[MamaPan]

I am the same as Divvy in how i feel about the importance of it (and I am also in melb but didnt grow up here) - and my mum was a single mum who put me through a private school with a lot of hard work and I now realise juggling!
I think it depends on the school... and the kids and the family and friends...
there are so many reasons for me choosing the school i did...
my boys will go from kinder just bc i love the school and the community and the philosophy... it may mean we miss out on some things as a family but this is really important to me. that said, i have a good income and so does dh so we can still do holidays etc too (i think, at the moment not but this is a tough time for us) - but when i think of the fees it does make me think harder about it.
I live opposite a great public school and i see the benefits of that too (all friends living 5 mins away, local community etc) - but this has been the right choice for us.
So for my famuily i would choose the school but there are lots of factors that come into that for each family.

[wysiwyg]

Is all interesting - not being from Melbourne but living here now I suppose my views might change overtime on the importance of a particular school. Here or the UK have never been asked about what school went to, University yes but school no - I would think it also very much depends on your profession - and can see in yours Divvy that it probably comes up more than in many others.