Saying one doesn't believe in hospitals for normal birth doesn't make them anti-choice, just anti-hospital
I am pro-choice, I am anti-hospital for normal birth. I can believe that till the cows come home, it's never going to become a political movement on my part. Hopsitalisation is too much part of our culture now (since last century when medicos convinced us it was because of them we had better births, yet there is a lot they leave out of the equation that has led to better birthing outcomes, not least of which is vastly improved diets and general hygiene practices which improve health over the lifespan...much more than just at the time of birthing in hospital) for that to happen.
There is nothing unfounded in someone saying there is too much risk in having a normal birth in hospital - those concerns are very real and quite founded! That's why being railroaded into a hospital birth is not only offensive, it's a violation of a woman's informed choice. There is no polar opposite being proposed and never will be - where women are railroaded into homebirths against their will - because that's taking choice out of it. Whatever your reasons for wanting a hospital birth is fine with me. It's when policy is formed at the expense of women who don't hold ideas of better care in hospital - i.e. the perception of increased safety over the facts, which is what has driven policy thus far and is informing the 'good' minister into denying indemnity insurance to private middies.
So, I have personal, empirical as well as political reasons for wanting homebirth (the campaign to marginalise midwifery started centuries ago) as a choice without sending my favourite midwife bankrupt after having to pay a fine for doing her trained job! I want to CHOOSE my midwife and not be precluded from homebirth because I refuse to undergo what are presumed to be 'routine' prenatal tests that I object to, or because I'm over a certain age (risk factors are combinatorial, I think lots of caregivers forget this!!).
The hospital HB plans will make homebirth an option for women who would ordinarily qualify for birth centre births, and we already know how narrow that criteria is - there will only be further restrictions on these, surely. So, no, it's not a 'win' for true homebirth.
And my midwife team are set to still be unemployed after July next year