Monnie, at this stage, you essentially have 3 OB's making an uneducated opinion about your best option for birthing, so don't be swayed by the "2 out of 3" that think a c/s is the way to go - none of them have looked into your situation specifically yet. Your current OB is going to be the OB caring for you during your birth, whichever way you choose to go, so you need to feel confident in his opinion, and confident in your own knowledge and preferences. If you're scared of uterine rupture, ask your OB to find out as much as he can about the real risks of your uterus rupturing, and what that would mean for you, and also ask him to find out what are the risks associated with you having a c/s (there might be specific things related to your previous surgery). You need to know the risks of both before you can make an educated decision for yourself.