My dh caught #2, I had him at home though. I didn't even realise dh had gotten into the bathtub too, except the head popped out and I could hear dh tell me, look Nelle there's the head and say I was doing good. So I didn't really think twice about it, lol, and I imagine if we'd been in a hospital dh would have probably said he didn't feel confident to catch.

But yeah, I'd definitely let him catch again, depending on how things were going at the time.