A question from my DH

[AliBaby]

I'd go option 2.

For me its the convenience of being closer to work! Makes such a big difference. Save time, money, etc.

[fionas]

Well, I was going to say option 1 based on location, location, location and presumably it will appreciate more than option 2.

BUT, if you think that reselling option 2 won't be a problem and you'll be able to pay off more in the meantime, then yes that's a good option too.

It really depends on how much you think each property will be worth in five years time. Have a look at prices in each burb from five years ago - that should help you make a decision.

[Inanna]

Take one. Don't do dodgy areas... Quality of life is important, you need to make life as easy as possible. Close to work. Walk to parks...

[mrsmac]

I agree with Inanna, I would always take the better area, I'd rather love in the worst house in a good area than a great house in a bad one.
Having said that if it's not too bad it would be OK.