Pandora, isn't St Kevin's in Toorak?? That's not too far from Carnegie - closer than Mentone anyhow. Only a few stations by train. I often saw lots of St Kev's kids on the train on my way to school and I'm not too far from Carnegie. Unless I'm thinking of a completely different school!!! At least I thought it was St Kevin's...green, blue, yellow striped blazer...???

Anyway, there are so many girls' schools around that area - it's a matter of trying to find the one you like best and it gets so overwhelming! Go to lots of open days and ask other parents.