I have tried all three and am back to scraping now!

I did invest in the LS but found it didn't work on our toilet. The water pressure was abysmal and I could not get any poo off at all so ended up having to scrape anyway. I think the pressure problem related to our house, we are upstairs in a warehouse apartment. I don't notice any problem with water pressure in any other taps but our toilet water pressure is terrible so the LS is a failure.

So, I have resigned to scrape. I do like using the liners, (really like avoiding scraping as my girls never seem to manage solid poos) but can't seem to get to the shop easily to get them when we run low. We are out at the moment and I am coping without. I don't mind the cost with DD2 at this age (18 months) as she doesn't tend to need to many changes a day so I can get away with using fewer liners. I can sometimes predict which nappy change will need the liner too so I can save it for the poo of the day. I do find that Murphy's law leads to DH doing the nappy change just before her poo and he never remembers to use a liner Now, if he would do the nappy change after the poo, I am sure he would always remember!!

Scraping hasn't been too bad. I can't believe how ok I have become about 'handling poo'!