If I were ranking them, I'd say: BBH petites, then Itti SIOs, then Itti AIOs and then MagicAlls. For fit, at any rate. Hubby hated washing/ folding the petites, too confusing for him.

And I like bamboo fitteds better than any of them. Maybe stick with what you know... or try Cute Tooshies Candies, for another one in the mix. They're a better fit than Ittis, easier to wash than petites.