It sounds to me you are on the right track.
My dad is BIG into this sort of stuff and from what hes told me and what hes been told and read, if you want a good result and not someone trying to make some cash from you, you need to be drawn to the particular phsycic. You will feel inside, instincts, guides or whatever, who is right.
It sounds like maybe that sign is drawing you in, which is what is suppose to happen.

Good luck with it.