Never fear girls - I am here!
I currently use a combination of Bumgenius' and Rumparooz. I personally prefer the Bumgenius but the Rumparooz are pretty good also. The leg channels on the Rumparooz really are as good as the reviews say, nothing escapes those buggers!

The reasons I like the Bumgenius' are mostly personal - i.e. things that don't work for me but might be just fine for some one else - but I'll list them anyway.

- My girl is a bit prone to nappy rash and I find the Rumparooz cause this slightly more than the BG. Not sure why cause I think they are basically the same material?? This is only really a problem when the weather is warm (rash is not much of a problem in cooler weather) so perhaps the Rumparooz is making her slightly warmer?? If there is any difference it is pretty minimal.

- The rumparooz are a bit harder to stuff. This doesn't bother me but DH complains everytime he does some stuffing.

- The pocket opening on the rumparooz comes open all the time so the insert comes into contact with her skin. I fixed this with a press stud sewn onto the opening 'flaps'.

- The shape of the rumparooz on my girl is not as good as the BG. This might just be her shape, but the cut in at the waist more so they make more of a 'round' shape around her butt instead of the more 'straight up and down' shape of the BG. Not sure if that description makes any sense at all.....

HTH

PS I haven't used any Minilalas but my friends that have them are all selling theirs because they don't get on with them.