To answer your 'what are your thoughts' question - Personally I would not use, although they are both pretty names they are very popular at the moment and I agree with the 'too much of a fad name' comment.

On the other hand, this is why I didn't share DD1's name, I did not want to hear anyones comments, once she was born and named no-one dared say a bad thing, not that anyone could her name is beautiful (to me ).

If you love it, use it, that is all that really matters.