thread: If I have to call an ambulance?

Hybrid View

Previous Post Previous Post   Next Post Next Post
  1. #1
    Registered User

    Jan 2010
    1,975

    I'm a paramedic in Vic, not sure of NSW regulations but they are usually pretty similar to ours... There are no hard and fast rules regarding transporting accompanying children in the ambulance in Vic, but there is certainly a preference not to. It is up to the discretion of the crew who attend to you and they will make a decision based on the urgency of transporting you to hospital. Most paramedics will exhaust all other options (relatives/neighbours...) before agreeing to transport you with two accompanying young children. Assuming you are attended by a two person crew (not carrying any student observers) there are two additional seats in the ambulance; the front passenger seat and another behind the head of the stretcher. Neither is fitted with child restraints or bolts to attach a child restraint, ergo a child cannot safely be transported in either of these seats. Given you have time to arrange care for your kids if you should go into labour whilst your DH is away (the neighbours down the road sound like a good place to start), I would suggest that you do so. As a mother myself, I would not find it an acceptable plan to transport my 4 and 2 year old children unrestrained to hospital. You would also have an issue at the hospital itself in terms of who will watch your children whilst you deliver as hospitals are understaffed and won't have anyone available to babysit.

    Your children will not be left at home alone by paramedics under any circumstances. If things are progressing normally, I would be prepared to risk delivery at home and await the arrival of someone to care for your children. Should immediate transport to hospital be clinically indicated (a medical emergency which demands transport with lights and sirens), your children would come with us - but again, as a mother I would be very uncomfortable with my young kids sitting in an ambulance traveling under lights and sirens, not appropriately restrained.

    In Vic your newborn baby is automatically covered by family ambulance membership and you would not receive a bill. You should check with NSW.

    As an aside, Cassius, there are absolutely no circumstances where I would agree to travel as a passenger in a patient's private vehicle to attend to a child. If the patient requires my clinical skills, that patient needs to be in my ambulance. In my 15 years as a paramedic, I have never had a parent refuse to allow the transport of a sick child in my ambulance, although parents do often want there children transported by ambulance when it is not necessary and they would be far safer in their car seat in a private vehicle! I would not ever compromise my own safety by traveling in the vehicle of a stranger, possibly one who is stressed or panicking due to an unwell child. Similarly, if the child's condition demands my paramedical skills, a cramped private vehicle presents avoidable OH&S issues as well as lacking access to the full gamut of my equipment. I am surprised - and somewhat concerned - to hear that one of my colleagues has done this, and also surprised that I have not heard about it as it is certainly not common behaviour.

  2. #2
    Registered User

    Feb 2010
    on a big patch of paradise.
    3,720

    Thanks so much for that reply nickle. Was what I was thinking and I guess it is like you said, it will all depend on who comes and the situation.

    DH left today. Legs are firmly crossed now

  3. #3
    Registered User

    Mar 2008
    North Northcote
    8,065

    As an aside, Cassius, there are absolutely no circumstances where I would agree to travel as a passenger in a patient's private vehicle to attend to a child. If the patient requires my clinical skills, that patient needs to be in my ambulance. In my 15 years as a paramedic, I have never had a parent refuse to allow the transport of a sick child in my ambulance, although parents do often want there children transported by ambulance when it is not necessary and they would be far safer in their car seat in a private vehicle! I would not ever compromise my own safety by traveling in the vehicle of a stranger, possibly one who is stressed or panicking due to an unwell child. Similarly, if the child's condition demands my paramedical skills, a cramped private vehicle presents avoidable OH&S issues as well as lacking access to the full gamut of my equipment. I am surprised - and somewhat concerned - to hear that one of my colleagues has done this, and also surprised that I have not heard about it as it is certainly not common behaviour.
    That's why i mentioned that i thought it was weird. It was against my own judgement but DH insisted and the paramedic agreed. Not entirely sure where you are going with your aside? I also think that you jumped to a big conclusion in saying that we REFUSED to transport her by ambulance - as if we would. this was not the case, my DH asked if she could travel in the car with us, the paramedics agreed and said that one would travel with us and brought all his bits and bobs.
    I understand that it was unusual. but i need to clarify that we did not under ANY circumstance refuse to transport her by ambulance. we called them in the first place because we knew that she needed assistance.

  4. #4
    Registered User

    Jan 2010
    1,975

    Hey Cassius, the only place I'm going is to make it known to anyone reading this thread that it is not considered acceptable practise for a paramedic to accompany a patient in a private vehicle for the reasons I have stated. You stated that your DH 'freaked out' and 'desperately wanted to drive...' - we see a lot of freaked out and desperate people and it is the job of the paramedic to manage not just the patient but anyone else on scene, particularly parents if we are dealing with a paediatric patient. Often, the best scene control is to clear all bystanders but this is not usually appropriate when dealing with a young child and his or her parents. The fact that you state that you didn't refuse transport by ambulance leaves me even more perplexed. If you and your DH were prepared for your child to be transported by ambulance - despite a preference to transport in your private vehicle - why on earth did the paramedic climb in your car? To be clear, I am not insulting you or your DH, I am concerned at the inappropriate actions of one of my colleagues. I do think it is important to clarify in this thread that a paramedic should not have travelled with a patient in a private vehicle so that anyone reading this will not expect the same actions from a paramedic should they ever have need to call an ambulance themselves.

    I see that you are in Melbourne, but I don't know what area you live in. If you would like to PM the date of ambulance attendance and the address the ambulance was dispatched to, I would be very pleased to follow up the issue so that the crew that made this decision can be made aware of the reasons their actions were inappropriate. If you are not comfortable doing so, my only recourse is to make it clear in this public forum that these paramedics made a very poor decision.

  5. #5
    Moderator

    Dec 2006
    Smidgen-ville
    3,736

    I'm a paramedic in Vic, not sure of NSW regulations but they are usually pretty similar to ours... There are no hard and fast rules regarding transporting accompanying children in the ambulance in Vic, but there is certainly a preference not to.
    That's interesting nickle, the crew I spoke to said there was a rule -no children. I guess it's much easier for them to say that than, it's at our discretion and we don't want to because we don't think it's safe. If they say its a rule, perhaps they get less arguments.

    Kazzo - you're right, I'm sure nothing will happen!

  6. #6
    Registered User

    Mar 2008
    North Northcote
    8,065

    That's interesting nickle, the crew I spoke to said there was a rule -no children. I guess it's much easier for them to say that than, it's at our discretion and we don't want to because we don't think it's safe. If they say its a rule, perhaps they get less arguments.
    when i had the PPH at home 5 weeks post partum the ambos were also adamant that they couldnt take my 5 week old with me. it made sense as i was all woozy and the paramedic said that it would not be safe. so DH had to drive with kids and meet us there. TBH i couldnt really imagine kids actually fitting in the ambulance lol...all pretty teeny in there once you and the paramedic are in there!

  7. #7
    Registered User

    Feb 2010
    on a big patch of paradise.
    3,720

    when i had the PPH at home 5 weeks post partum the ambos were also adamant that they couldnt take my 5 week old with me. it made sense as i was all woozy and the paramedic said that it would not be safe. so DH had to drive with kids and meet us there. TBH i couldnt really imagine kids actually fitting in the ambulance lol...all pretty teeny in there once you and the paramedic are in there!
    5wk old I can understand. Who would hold a newborn if the mum was unable to when been taken to hospital?