thread: Holding children back = new trend

Hybrid View

Previous Post Previous Post   Next Post Next Post
  1. #1
    Registered User

    Mar 2008
    Sunny QLD!
    720

    But see, she wont. She wont turn 18 until the year after she finish's year 12. She will turn 17 during year 12 (well at the start basically).

    So that could work in her favor, or against.

    i.e having a car in year 12 would be great, BUT, being able to get into clubs, could distract her away from studies...

    hmmmmprh

  2. #2
    BellyBelly Life Subscriber

    Jun 2005
    Blue Mountains
    5,086

    I was 17 in the January of year 12. I was driving to school, but couldn't drink haha. I didn't feel behind or like I was missing anything.

  3. #3
    Moderator

    Oct 2004
    In my Zombie proof fortress.
    6,449

    But see, she wont. She wont turn 18 until the year after she finish's year 12. She will turn 17 during year 12 (well at the start basically).

    So that could work in her favor, or against.

    i.e having a car in year 12 would be great, BUT, being able to get into clubs, could distract her away from studies...

    hmmmmprh
    I found when I was in year 12 those who wanted to go out did, regardless of if they were old enough or not, as that is what their friends were doing. Also not everyone who turned 18 suddenly went out clubbing and neglected their studies, it is really one of those things that depends on personality.

  4. #4
    Registered User

    Dec 2005
    In Bankworld with Barbara
    14,222

    TBH, not being 18 in year 12 (january baby so I didn't turn 18 till the following year) certainly didn't stop me from drinking and partying...

  5. #5
    Registered User

    May 2004
    Shepparton
    4,871

    I put DD#3 into 3yo fungroup this year and she was 4 in March. So 4yo kinda next year and school in 2011...

    I think most teachers see that most parents keep their kids home for longer so recommended that because there would be more than 12 months between her and some of the other kids. I KNow Violet would be more ready for school next year and would love it... but I don't want her to be at a disadvantage because of a few months....

    I dunno....

  6. #6
    Registered User

    Dec 2005
    6,706

    I didn't turn 18 until the February AFTER I finished year 12. This didn't disadvantage me in any way, shape or form. I wasn't exactly a socialite so it didn't bother me at all that others were out drinking and partying - I was happier at home with my nose in a book. For all that, I was dux of my year, and pretty bored through most of my early years of schooling. If I'd been kept back things would have been extremely painful for all concerned.

    You need to look at where she's at NOW rather than what she may be wanting to do in 12-13 years time. If she's ready for school next year, then send her.

    I suspect people are keeping kids back the extra year with private schools so that they're not out an extra year of school fees of their child needs to repeat. But not that long ago I was reading an article that said the "trend" was reversing - that parents were finding it more affordable to put their children in school when they are turning 5 (as opposed to 6 like this school is pushing) because it's cheaper than paying for another year of childcare.

    BW

  7. #7
    Registered User

    Dec 2005
    In Bankworld with Barbara
    14,222

    BW, I know several mums who have done that and the poor little things were in no way ready for school and with one family in particular, all of them have repeated kindergarten so far and I expect her DD that started this year to be in kindergarten with my DD next year. With public schooling there is little or next to no cost at all. Much much cheaper than several $1000's for child care

  8. #8
    BellyBelly Member

    Oct 2007
    Ever so slowly going crazy...
    2,268

    I know some people think that if she's ready now, just send her, but it does affect her whole schooling, not just one year.

    She will go to high school at 11, not 12 turning 13. You could find a lot of her friends are teenagers, and she's 11, with kids up to 18 yrs old in the same school.

    If she moves out after high school for uni or work or even travel, she will be 17, so unable to get leases etc. and could be that year behind in maturity to be living out of home alone and out in the real world, especially if she travels...

    I didn't want my kids (read;daughter!) with boys up to 2 years older than her, in the same year, being her boyfriend. In school I think 99% date their own year...she could be 14, dating a class mate, 16!!! I do know she could date anyone, but a bit hard to explain she should date the boys a year below her!!

    Please dont think I'm trying to sway you, just giving all the reasons we done it the way we did. Some may feel our reasons are silly, but to us they are very real and valid!!

    Only you know your daughter best, and can predict how she will cope with her schooling babe....