I went to a Methodist school but my parents and myself were all Catholic. It wasn't an issue for us. There were Jewish, Muslim, Christian (Uniting, Protestant, Anglican, Methodist and Presbyterian) and Catholic students, along atheists and agnostics, at the school.

It really depends on the school - but I'd follow your heart. If you don't believe that the school is right for you and DD, then choose another school.

My DSs go to the local primary near my parents' home because it's more convenient. It's 12-16 mins drive from my house. I have a fabulous, fantastic primary school right around the corner, but it's not practical, so they go near my parents. Horses for courses and all that.