thread: NAPLAN Results

Hybrid View

Previous Post Previous Post   Next Post Next Post
  1. #1
    Registered User

    Oct 2006
    Sydney NSW
    4,837

    Exactly!! Until we have a national curriculum the whole system of NAPLAN is flawed.

  2. #2
    Registered User

    Jan 2010
    In Love land with my family :D
    1,512

    oh, so in nsw i shouldnt be worried if she is below ave?

  3. #3
    Registered User

    Dec 2005
    In Bankworld with Barbara
    14,222

    Nae, don't worry too much about it. I second what MrsMac said 100% it is a snapshot of your child's performance on that day. It gives you a good idea of how they are going, but when kids are assessed for learning, that assessing takes many forms - work done throughout the year, effort, improvement on previous assessments etc so it is best to look at the overall picture of her school reports etc rather than just the NAPLAN.

  4. #4
    Registered User

    Jan 2007
    7,197

    I would be looking at all of her maths work up until this point including previous reports as well as daily class work before this becomes a major concern. Get her to bring her maths workbook home and have a look at what she has been doing all term/year and what kind of errors she might be making and in what area. NAPLAN is hugely flawed as Mrsmac has pointed out. HUGE. Yes all the students do the work together but if she is in a composite grade for eg. they may have split the kids up or they may have split them up according to ability groups etc. Also sometimes they way they ask the questions in NAPLAN is really confusing. I was working through some things on it with some teachers and there were a few questions that as teachers we had to read 2-3 times to understand so imagine how difficult it would be for a yr3 or yr5 student to figure out under stress of a "test". The language used in some of the maths questions seriously needs to be looked at.

    Anyhoo tutoring may help but more so would just getting her to use maths in daily life, helping her find counting patterns, using clocks and time, helping with measurement in cooking, adding up in the supermarket, halving and dividing recipes and dinner and the list goes on. Just finding ways in everyday life to get her think mathematically will assist her more greatly than sitting down and working through a book with tutor, although if she does have very serious gaps in her knowledge then it may assist as well.

    HtH.

  5. #5
    Registered User

    Jan 2007
    on the sunny Eastern Shore
    1,165

    Just to crash...man...NAPLAN!! GRRRR!

    MrsMac (seems so funny to me, this is what the kids at school call me ) is so right. You should see how Tassie fares under NAPLAN then!! Shocking!

    National curriculum is what's needed!

    Anyhoo....I'd agree it's one day, and in all honesty it's not a very honest representation of the national "average".

    However if maths is already a concern for you then for sure, take it up with DD's teacher.

    I hope you get some direction.

    xxx

  6. #6
    Registered User

    Jan 2010
    In Love land with my family :D
    1,512

    Thanks everyone, I will raise the issue with her teacher & see what he has to say.

    I didnt realise there was such a gap with the naplan's .. what on earth is the point of doing them? Seems a bit absurd to me ... ?

  7. #7
    Registered User

    Oct 2006
    Sydney NSW
    4,837

    That's why teachers don't like it Naenae it IS totally absurd!!

    Becstar- when I taught the older kids thats what they called me too! My kindies manage to drag out a 3 syllable name into about 15 syllables!!

  8. #8
    Registered User

    Apr 2010
    Brisbane, Australia
    1,385

    Naenae- I think the other girls are completely right. NAPLAN is a day. It's a snapshot in time. I am a teacher and I taught year 5 through NAPLAN last year. Often students will do better or worse than predicted and I don't believe that NAPLAN is enough to base your opinion about your child's progress. She should have had a mid year report last term, how did she go in maths there?

    Until Australia has a national curriculum (starting to come in next year) the idea of having national testing is rediculous! How can you compare children in different states who are learning different things? Especially sine some states have had a prep year for ages and some have only just started having prep. This is the real reason that teachers are against NAPLAN and Myschool (which compares school based on NAPLAN) it isn't that we don't want to be accountable, we just thinlk it should wait until the system is fairer. Sorry- I'll get off my soapbox now! Oops......