I have a black Fossil wallet that closes with a press stud. Nothing special but it has lots of card spaces which is what I look for first.

Before that I had a dark red Colorado one for about 3 years. It was given to me by one of the day care families and while I didn't love it at first it grew on me and was very sad to let it go in the end, partly because of sentimental value and partly because it had become like an old friend.