Help! We're stuck!

[Floweryfields]

I don't think any of the mentioned choices of first name are classical. Eden is okish, but more trendy then classical. Shayla is very modern and (not really hippie,more ocka maybe) in my very honest opinion. Coral is very old, but I don't think it's classical.
Rose however is lovely.

[Phteven]

Edith is similar to Eden but more classical and prettier.

[Floweryfields]

Edith is similar to Eden but more classical and prettier.

Yes I agree.

[LionsandBears]

Eden is pretty common. It's nice, but I wouldn't call it classical. Shyla seems like a made up name to me. I personally don't like it but that doesn't mean others can't

If you like classical, pretty names like those you mentioned, why not use Charlotte, Annabelle etc? They're lovely.

[Maruschke]

Can I be honest? The only one I like is Eden, and I think that is newer, not quite classical. I love Ivy as a classical name.

[MummaBee]

I love Shyla reminds me of the kid off transformers not sure if its the same name but I love it

[reneenay]

Shayla is very modern and (not really hippie,more ocka maybe)

Lol funny you should say that Ausgirl! My cousin (back when we were picking names for my DS) said Shyla sounds like Sheila, which in my opinion is verrrry ocka. That comment stuck with me ever since.

I wouldn't say we are going for classical names, I'd like to think feminine I suppose. well...I hope