I think I have narrowed it down to two names, some opinions would be lovely...

[LionsandBears]

If you're going for Italian, I've always loved Chiara. Chiara Sofia would be sweet

I like Gabriella Sofia too.
or Amelia Sofia
or Liliana Sofia

I love Lucia Bella - so pretty

[Tiff+2]

Freya is such a beautiful name, LOVE IT LOVE IT LOVE IT (I wish DH loved it too!).

[Nicoletta24]

how about the name Harper? Who likes that?
Harper Sofia
or Harper Ruby...............
or Aria
Amalia
Edie
Pania
Coco
Lila
Lena
Roma
Violetta.......................

[berrme]

I thought you had it down to a few. lol.
I like Freya and Pania. In my opinion Harper doesn't flow nicely with Sofia like the previous options did. I wish I was Italian... so many pretty names that I would just feel silly using with no Italian heritage at all.
I think Ariella would get boob jokes made at her expense. Kids really aren't very nice.

[Butterfly Child]

i love Sophia and Ariella too, im unsure of freya its ok but out of the 3 i like those to the best

[ktdancer]

I love the name Freya.
I taught a little girl called Freya and she was the loveliest little thing ever, so whenever I hear that name I think of her