I prefer Anika but think it would suit a different middle name perhaps (although it wouldn't matter at all- you barely say first and middle names in the same sentence).
Some other A name suggestions;
Amiah
Aysha
Ayla
Aubrey
Avalie/Avaley
Aleiya (Ah-lay-a)
Ariane
Arielle
Alira
Aramei/Aremai (ending sounds like 'may')
Aralyn
Akeiba
Amber

Oh, I do love A names.....