Yes, opinions are one thing but unnecessary procedures to women's bodies and/or the baby, (esp. going against studies or evidence!) is not like picking the colour for the nursery, it has long term health/psychological effects.

With the reputation thing, depends who you speak to - I hear midwives who want to leave the system in Brisbane and certain groups of Obs. High tech birth and bedside manner doesn't mean high standard of healthcare. Just something to consider and I am not judging anyone based on who they choose for care - we are all attracted to certain people. But like anything, I think it's good to know pro's and con's or you may not end up with what you hope for. Some people are not phased with a medical birth, but if you hope to avoid that, then this is something that is good to know so you can make an informed decision.