Spice- well its the only one i have used so have no comparison but i use it with bubs on one side and express from the other and it doesnt bother her... she still falls asleep... It did say it was a quiet one... It came in a pack with bottles teats etc plus little bag to keep everything in... I searched and searched... They also sell single ones that are auto electric... i have noticed some are electric but you need to press a button to release and suck. The cherub double one i have has 2 settings one quick pump (like when bubs forst starts sucking and the second setting is longer sucking for the thicker milk and you can choose to pump right or left or both together. I brought one as my supply wasnt the best but now i'm not having as many issues... Just need to remember to keep up using it... (even though i cant get DD to drink my EBM from a bottle...) I'm freezing it though...

Even on the cherub website there not as expensive as other brands... i lost a few auctions before i won there pretty popular. mite take you a few goes.. but still a double pump under $200 i still would have paid... so great to pop it on both sides and away you go... usually for me 15 mins max and i have 2 full bottles... Its great.

Good luck