I think that this really is a personal choice and everyones opinions are going to be different. I dont think that we will get it done if we are having a boy, I can just hear DP arguing about it now! "i'm not c'ed so my boy wont be c'ed!" But if it was required due to a medical isssue then I would have no problems with it. My nephew had to get c'ed when really young because he was having problems with urinating... so that would be one of the medical issues that would have me say yes to getting my son c'ed.