12

thread: Fair-Trade Chocolate and Child Slavery

  1. #1

    Mar 2004
    Sparta
    12,662

    Fair-Trade Chocolate and Child Slavery

    mmmmm Chocolate. We all love it but it has a dark side (and I'm not talking 80% cocoa).

    Bitter life of chocolate's child slaves

    CHOCOLATE: it's the most popular treat used as a reward for our kids, but what most Australians don't realise is that every time they indulge their children with a chocolate snack, they could be unwittingly supporting the enslavement of thousands of abused children in West Africa.

    The world's largest cocoa producers ? the Ivory Coast and Ghana ? have been found guilty by the United Nations and US Congress of exporting cocoa made by trafficked and enslaved children.

    It is estimated more than 100,000 children work in the Ivory Coast's cocoa industry under "the worst forms of child labor," and that about 10,000 are slaves.

    As the Ivory Coast produces 43 per cent of the world's cocoa, it is likely almost half the chocolate products sold in Australia could be linked to child slavery.

    In the last financial year, Victorian chocolate manufacturers alone imported 3 million kilograms of Ivory Coast cocoa paste.

    The Confectionary Manufacturers Association ? of which Nestle, Cadbury Schweppes and Mars Confectionery are members ? cannot confirm if chocolate sold here has passed through the hands of child slaves. But they can offer no guarantees that the chocolate coating Australia's three biggest-selling bars ? Cherry Ripe, Kit Kat and Mars ? does not contain slave-tainted cocoa.

    Association spokesman David Greenwood said it was notoriously difficult to identify children held as slaves or bonded workers because most plantations were family businesses in which children have traditionally laboured alongside their parents.

    Adding to the confusion were large numbers of children moving to the Ivory Coast to escape the desperate poverty in neighbouring Mali, he said.

    But the Salvation Army's anti-slavery co-ordinator, social justice director Captain Danielle Strickland, says this approach is not good enough. She believes manufacturers have a responsibility to urgently find out who produces their cocoa.

    "Given that Cote d'Ivoire (Ivory Coast) produces 43 per cent of the world's cocoa you could say there is a 43 per cent chance your favourite chocolate bar has some beans produced by child slaves," she said.

    "There is no doubt the issue is complex, but if you are producing something you have a responsibility to find out what you are buying."

    The Australian Fair Trade Association and welfare organisations such as Oxfam and World Vision also want Australian chocolate lovers to start thinking about the suffering behind the indulgent treat.

    Australians are the world's fourth highest consumers of chocolate, gobbling down an average 10 Easter eggs and between nine and 11 kilograms of chocolate per person a year.

    But in the Ivory Coast, farmers earn less for a kilo of cocoa beans than we pay for a Snickers bar.

    "Chocolate is the perfect case study for urban awareness of our connection to food producers," said Anne Lanyon, co-ordinator of the Columban Centre for Peace, Ecology and Justice, which promotes consumer awareness to schoolchildren. "It is our responsibility to be aware."

    Australian Bureau of Statistics and Customs documents confirm that Australians are among the world's biggest consumers of Ivory Coast and Ghanaian-based chocolate directly imported as cocoa beans, paste, powder, butter and liquor. Additional millions of dollars worth of Ivory Coast, Ghanaian, other West African, Malaysian and Indonesian cocoa is imported via Singapore, the cocoa processing hub of South-East Asia.

    In 2001, the international news agency Knight Ridder exposed the use of child slaves on Ivory Coast and Ghana cocoa farms.

    It led the US Congress to draft legislation in which the chocolate manufacturing industry agreed to a voluntary protocol to end abusive and forced child labour on cocoa farms by July 2005. But little has changed, says the US-based International Labor Rights Fund.

    "The cocoa companies trumpeted a few pilot programs, but continue to purchase and reap profits from child labour cocoa," the fund reports.

    "These child workers labour for long, punishing hours, using dangerous tools and facing frequent exposure to dangerous pesticides as they travel great distances in the gruelling heat.

    "Those who labour as slaves must also suffer frequent beatings and other cruel treatment."

    A recent Pilot Labour Survey in Cocoa Production in Ghana found 2.47 million children aged between five and seven are being used in economic activities across 600,000 small farming communities.

    But solving the issue of child slavery will not be simple, according to Mr Greenwood. "(Slavery) is a very emotive issue, so there is a perception that everybody is in an abusive situation," he said.

    "It is a matter of a few thousand slaves ? which is abhorrent and should not exist ? but that is on a scale of 1.5 to 2 million farms.

    "Boycotts will not help anybody. Hand-outs to people without change will achieve nothing."

    International chocolate manufacturers have pledged to introduce a form of approved labour certification for cocoa farmers from mid-2008.

    The Ivory Coast Government has pledged to reform its cocoa sector before the end of March 2008 and last month froze the bank account of the Coffee and Cocoa Farmers' Development Fund, citing corruption and embezzlement of money meant for growers.

    source - The Age
    From this fantastic blog a list of slave free chocolate.
    Consumption Rebellion: Updating my list of slave-free chocolate in Australia

    Totally Slave-Free
    The following chocolate brands are fairtrade certified.

    Scarborough Fair
    Cocolo
    Maya Gold (from Green and Blacks)
    Alter Eco
    Dagoba (not their whole range - again, look for the Label)
    Chocolatier Milk and Dark Chocolate Things - available in selected Coles and on counters in Starbucks
    Oxfam Shops carry a range of Oxfam Fairtrade Certified chocolates
    Totally Slave-Free, but....

    The following brands are slave-free. However, ethically-sourced cocoa is not a core value in their business. Rather, it is more a by-product of either gaining more profits (by appealing to ethical consumers); or because it is a condition of them gaining organic accreditation. As a result, I believe these chocolate brands should be kept on a "watching brief" as I believe that if accreditation standards change or if ethical consumption proves to be unprofitable, then these chocolates *may* end up buying cocoa harvested by child slaves.

    Green and Blacks - organic chocolate that is also slave free. Having said that, this brand is owned by Cadbury's who are NOT slave-free.
    Kaoka
    Rupunzel
    Tava
    Abundant Earth
    Endangered Species (also carries a strong environmental message and 10% of profits go to save endangered animal species)- I've put Endangered Species here because they are saying they are carrying out audits on their suppliers BUT those audits are no longer independent. Still they are listing their suppliers, so to my knowledge they are slave-free.
    Just Organic
    Any other chocolate that has Australian Certified Organic accreditation. (There are heaps of accreditation systems but ACO requires that all ingredients in the product are produced in accordance with Internation Labour Laws (this includes no slavery in the production process).
    Chocolate that has NASAA Certified Organic Accreditation.
    *Not* Slave-Free but....
    These brands are not slave-free, however they have policies or programmes in place that try to minimise the more negative practices of slavery (ie beatings, torture etc) in their chocolate. They have education programmes for their producers in a (small) effort to change the more abusive nature of slavery.
    Cocoa Farm - have concrete plans in place to harvest cocoa ONLY from Australian crops. At this stage its unclear whether their crops are mature enough now to use in their chocolate or whether this is a future plan of theirs. I am emailing them now to see what is happening.
    Cadbury Range - including Picnic, and Fry's Turkish (owned by Cadbury Schweppes) EDIT: 5 March 2009 - Cadbury UK has announced that they hope to have gained Fairtrade accreditation for their Cadbury Dairy Milk range by the end of 2009!! To date they have not said anything about applying for Fairtrade accreditation for their subsidiaries too (including Cadbury Australia). So watch this space!!
    Streets (owned by Unilever)
    Arnotts - now apparently have ONE supplier who belong to the Cocoa Initiative. Not a great step but at least its a step.
    Definitely Use Slaves and They Don't Care

    The following companies absolutely disgust me with their absolute commitment to profit at the cost of abuse and deaths of children. Note that while many of the companies below belong to the International Cocoa Initiative, I have yet to see any real commitment by these companies to actually do more than just pay lip service to this issue.
    Entire Nestle Range
    Hershey (actually has a policy to *not* reveal its cocoa sources, despite a Supreme Court action to do so.... legal case still going...)
    Mars Company (includes M&Ms)
    Lindt
    More here here and here.

  2. #2
    Registered User
    Add krysalyss on Facebook

    Feb 2007
    on the move.....
    2,745

    The oxfam brand of chocolate is great for those who like cadbury style chunky chocolate like I do - sooo yummy! You can buy it online now (they used to not post chocolate because of the melting factor).

    Cadbury Range - including Picnic, and Fry's Turkish (owned by Cadbury Schweppes) EDIT: 5 March 2009 - Cadbury UK has announced that they hope to have gained Fairtrade accreditation for their Cadbury Dairy Milk range by the end of 2009!! To date they have not said anything about applying for Fairtrade accreditation for their subsidiaries too (including Cadbury Australia). So watch this space!!
    Now that would be awesome!

  3. #3
    Registered User

    Jan 2005
    Down by the ocean
    6,110

    I loooove my chocolate and do quite often buy fair trade. My local coles sell a bit of it now. Chocolateir and there is another one which name escapes me ATM.
    Green and Blacks used to be fair trade but now they are only certified organic as far as I can see on the label which is a bit of a downer

    I hope cadbury does go fair trade by the end of the year!
    Last edited by ~Raven~; June 29th, 2009 at 08:50 PM. : brain fart moment

  4. #4

    Mar 2004
    Sparta
    12,662

    Problem is it's not just block chocolate that uses the cocoa. It's even harder to find fair trade hot chocolate and chocolate biscuits and fair trade cooking chocolate or cocoa and I haven't yet found a fair trade version of Nutella or chocolate ice-cream.

  5. #5
    Registered User

    Nov 2005
    Where the heart is
    4,360

    I'm not a big eater of commercial chocolate, so it hasn't been hard to avoid these companies. Pity about the M&M's - have loved the peanut ones till now
    Free-trade chocky tastes better because they're far more likely to make a nicer chocky in the first place. My first proper job was at The Chocolate Box and the things I learned about chocky making turned me right off the mainstream blocks etc. Belgian chocolate is so much nicer and properly made - stirred for days and days, not hours (that's the difference between good and ordinary chocolate, it seems). Now, to source a Belgian chocky that comes from reputable raw ingredients...
    That said, G&B's has been creeping into my life since I got a couple of freebie sample packs whilst on strike team duties during the Feb fires (it's not all stinky smoke and leaky hoses!) and that's when I decided that I love the cherry G&B's!
    Though G&B's is a Cadbury's owned brand, the fact that it's getting a bigger and bigger name will send the message about why people are making the switch.
    And quite frankly, for a little bit more money, you get a far better tasting chocky experience!

  6. #6
    Registered User

    Jan 2005
    Down by the ocean
    6,110

    I had to duck down to coles before and the choc is called Cocolo Noice it is too!

  7. #7
    Registered User

    Dec 2005
    In Bankworld with Barbara
    14,222

    NOOOOOOOOOOOO! Not my beloved Lindt! I lurve their 80% cocoa dark choccie with coffee. And gold bunnies at easter..... I would love to try some alternatives but there seems to be so much that verges on being carob-like and I wouldn't feed carob to pigs! So it's really hard to find a great alternative, especially out here where there are no speciality shops.

    Sam, the only G&B that is fair trade was the Maya Gold one, it has citrus and spice overtones to it so it's not a plain choccy

  8. #8

    Mar 2004
    Sparta
    12,662

    I know. I loved Lindt too.

    I've been wondering about the sugar in Cadburys. It's not an issue in Australia because we have a thriving sugar industry of our own but the UK imports its sugar and lots of it would come from the developing world. I'm sure that in poorer countries sugar would have some of the same issues associated with the production of cocoa and coffee.

  9. #9
    Registered User

    Dec 2005
    In Bankworld with Barbara
    14,222

    hmmm good point. I wonder how you can find that out. I would be surprised if Cadbury aust even used Australian sugar as the price would be cheaper to get it in from OS.

  10. #10

    Mar 2004
    Sparta
    12,662

    Funny, after talking about this yesterday I got an email from Jasper and they have a fair-trade organic drinking chocolate now. They also have fair-trade organic coffee that I order online from them.
    About to put a choccy order in for winter mmmmm.....

    ETA - They've added fair trade sugar to their stock as well but I think I'll stick with the CSR organic.

    ETA 2- All the fair trade drinking chocolate is out of stock but

  11. #11
    Registered User

    Jan 2010
    1

    Fair Trade Chocolates

    I loved your article. Just wanted to let you know the entire Green & Black's chocolate range is now Fair Trade certified.
    I was looking on the World Vision site and found this article
    World Vision

    More chocolate for us to enjoy while helping those in need

  12. #12
    Registered User

    Jan 2009
    A Pirate Ship
    3,627

    What a great thread to read just before Easter.... Wish I hadn't bought a bag of red tulip eggs Chocolate isn't a regular purchase in our house but I will know what to buy in the future

  13. #13
    Registered User
    Add C~Q on Facebook

    Oct 2006
    By the sea
    2,191

    I just had a look at the Jasper website and there is no way I can afford that for coffee Is there a cheaper fair trade option or is that about standard?

  14. #14

    Mar 2004
    Sparta
    12,662

    There are fair-trade brands at the supermarket. Coles had some reasonably priced coffee when I was last there and chocolate too.
    They put it on the top shelves so I like to pop a box down to eye level in front of a Nestle product

  15. #15
    Registered User
    Add CrazyLady on Facebook

    Aug 2009
    2,328

    There are fair-trade brands at the supermarket. Coles had some reasonably priced coffee when I was last there and chocolate too.
    They put it on the top shelves so I like to pop a box down to eye level in front of a Nestle product
    Going to do that next time i'm shopping

    I think I am completely off chocolate this easter!!

  16. #16
    Registered User

    Jul 2007
    melb
    8,498

    Cadburys packaging now says fair trade accredited.

  17. #17
    Registered User

    Jan 2005
    Down by the ocean
    6,110

    Cadburys packaging now says fair trade accredited.
    You beauty

  18. #18
    Registered User

    Apr 2009
    in the garden
    3,767

    NOOOOOOOOOOOO! Not my beloved Lindt!
    nooooo....

    Cadburys packaging now says fair trade accredited.
    Phew!!

12