The little fishing game - MIL bought the girls one the other day and it doesn't have magnets it's actually got a little hook so you have to be co-ordinated enough to get it IN the mouth and lift it out... not just let the magnet do the work.
The girls love it and DD1 has been playing it for hours, i love watching them play it and joining in.
We also bought a smurfs version of the pairs game - teaching DD1 is great fun and DD2 likes to join in... sometimes i remember where something was and help them just a little too